EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET WASHINGTON, D. C. 20503 DEPUTY DIRECTOR
FOR MANAGEMENT October 16, 2018 M-19-01 MEMORANDUM FOR THE HEADS OF EXECUTIVE DEPARTMENTS AND AGENCIES l~ I FROM: Margaret W eichert / Deputy Director for Management
Subject:
Request for Agency Feedback on the Federal Data Strategy The purpose of this memo is to provide an update on the development of the Federal Data Strategy and to solicit substantive feedback from agencies that are subject to the provisions of OMB Circular A-130, Managing Federal Information as a Strategic Resource. Agencies should forward this information to all bureaus that create, collect, acquire, process, disseminate, use, and store data and solicit feedback from personnel to maximize the usefulness of comments that OMB receives to this important strategy. Agencies should use the Federal Data Strategy website, to provide feedback within 30 days of the date of this memo.
Background
The President's Management Agenda lays out a long-term vision for modernizing the Federal Government in key areas that will improve the ability of agencies to deliver mission outcomes, provide excellent service, and effectively steward taxpayer dollars on behalf of the American people. Leveraging Data as a Strategic Asset is one of the 12 Cross-Agency Priority goals supporting this transformation. This Administration is committed to developing a long-term, comprehensive Federal Data Strategy supported by an action plan with appropriate performance measures.
The Federal Data Strategy will apply to agencies 1 responsible for data stewardship and information management. In general, these agencies are responsible for the following types of data:
1. Program data: Data generated in carrying out the administration of a government program or mission, such as processing benefit applications or tracking services received. These data can relate to individuals, businesses, and other institutions.
2. Statistical data: Data used to describe, estimate, or analyze the characteristics of groups, without identifying the individuals or organizations that constitute such groups, such as for research and evaluation.
3. Mission-support data: Program data focused on internal government operations that apply broadly across government, such as government spending, performance, or personnel.
1 "Agency" is defined in 44 U.S.C.
§4502.
The Federal Data Strategy is currently under development and, by the spring of 2019, will set forth principles, practices, and a year-one action plan to deliver a more consistent approach to federal data stewardship, access, and use. The principles provide the foundation for agencies, while the practices are aspirational goals for a 5- to 10-year horizon to further the principles, and the action steps are agency activities to implement the practices in any given year. The action plan will begin next year, and will be relevant to agencies that create, collect, acquire, process, disseminate, use, and store data.
The third quarter deliverables for the Federal Data Strategy are the final principles (Attachment 1) and draft practices (Attachment 2) for the Federal Data Strategy. The principles reflect revisions based on comments received from stakeholders and the public on previously released draft principles. The draft practices were developed by the Federal Data Strategy Working Groups with membership from numerous federal agencies and will be revised based on comments received from stakeholders, including from federal agency personnel.
The principles and practices will be published in the Federal Register on behalf of the Federal Data Strategy development team by the Department of Commerce, as well as on the Federal Data Strategy website, www.strategy.data.gov. Agencies should submit comments on the draft practices through the website. Revised practices will be released in January, along with a draft year-one action plan and a request for comments on the action plan.
Principles On behalf of the Federal Data Strategy development team, the Department of Commerce published a Request for Comments in the Federal Register on June 27, 2018. The request included a set of 10 draft principles for a comprehensive data strategy, and asked the public to “review and provide feedback on their clarity, appropriateness, completeness, and potential duplications.” Comments were also submitted through the Federal Data Strategy website. The request closed on July 27, and the website closed to comments on July 30. This process generated close to 100 comments related to the draft principles. Feedback on the draft principles was positive, and commenters offered many suggestions to improve the draft version, which have been incorporated in the 10 revised principles.
Draft Practices The draft practices are based on the work for the four Federal Data Strategy Working Groups, each centered on a specific strategic area: Enterprise Data Governance; Decision Making and Accountability; Access, Use, and Augmentation; and Commercialization, Innovation, and Public Use. The working groups are teams of Federal Data Fellows from across the Executive Branch, selected for their multidisciplinary experience and expertise in federal data. The working groups conducted research on practices, reviewed relevant federal policies such as OMB Circular A 130, Managing Information as a Strategic Resource, and incorporated comments from the public and federal agency personnel. The work of the separate groups was then synthesized into 47 draft practices.
The draft practices are intended to be consistent with the principles. These are practices that should occur on a regular basis and are continually relevant, are sufficiently general so as to be broadly applicable at most federal agencies, can gain broad consensus throughout the government, and are aspirational in the sense that they challenge federal agencies, practitioners, 2
and policymakers to improve. The practices are not characterized as “best practices,” as the broad variety of types and nuances of federal data mean that the “best” determination must be made at the operational level. The draft practices will be revised and further developed in response to comments. Specifically, comments are requested on the following questions: 1. What other framework(s) for organizing or classifying the practices would be most useful to Federal practitioners and other key stakeholders? For example, should they be classified according to whether they pertain to data creation or collection, processing, dissemination, use, storage, and disposition?
2. Are there any draft practices that should be omitted or modified?
3. Are there other practices, policies, or related conventions relevant to data creation or collection, processing, dissemination, use, storage, and disposition that are important to include among the draft practices?
4. Are the practices described so as to effectively identify objectives, outcomes, and goals?
5. Are the practices described so as to be helpful to a practitioners and data policymakers?
6. Propose recommended action steps that agencies should adopt or adapt over the next 5 to 10 years to implement each practice. For guidance in proposing action steps, use the following as examples of specific practices and associated action steps. These examples are provided for guidance only, and may not indicate year-one action steps.
• Practice: Prioritize Data Security
Example Action Steps
1. Leverage existing standards for comprehensive and high quality data management.
2. Define, implement, and maintain formal expectations throughout government for data oversight and transparency. • Practice: Connect Federal Spending to Outcomes
Example Action Steps
1. Publish interactive reports with spending, performance, and mission-support data that enables the public to interact with the data and create customizable tables and report. These interactive charts and graphics should be embedded in Federal websites such as USAspending.gov and performance.gov.
2. Standardize reporting data for federal grants to help make those data more accessible and useful. Attachments: Attachment 1: Principles for Leveraging Data as a Strategic Asset Attachment 2: Draft Practices for Leveraging Data as a Strategic Asset 3
Attachment 1 Principles for Leveraging Data as a Strategic Asset Federal data is both a strategic asset and a valuable national resource. It enables the government to carry out its mission and programs effectively. It provides the public with knowledge of the government, society, economy, and environment – past, present, and future. Federal data is also a means to ensure the accountability of government, to manage the government’s operations, and to maintain and enhance the performance of the Nation’s economy, public health, and welfare.
Appropriate access to federal data significantly enhances its value and the return on the Nation’s investment in its creation. The following principles are intended to guide the development of a comprehensive data strategy that encompasses federal and federally sponsored program, statistical, and mission-support data. These principles include concepts reflected in existing principles, such as those for the protection of personal information, for the management of information as an asset, for federal statistical agencies, and for federal evidence building. These principles will inform the development of practices and action steps for the Federal Data Strategy throughout the data lifecycle.
Mission Statement: The mission of the Federal Data Strategy is to fully leverage the value of federal data for mission, service, and the public good by guiding the Federal Government in practicing ethical governance, conscious design, and learning culture. Ethical Governance
1. Uphold Ethics:
Monitor and assess the implications of federal data practices for the public. Design checks and balances to protect and serve the public good.
2. Exercise Responsibility:
Practice effective data stewardship and governance. Employ sound data security practices, protect individual privacy, maintain promised confidentiality, and ensure appropriate access and use.
3. Promote Transparency:
Articulate the purposes and uses of federal data to engender public trust. Comprehensively document processes and products to inform data providers and users. Conscious Design
4. Ensure Relevance:
Protect the quality and integrity of the data. Validate that data are appropriate, accurate, objective, accessible, useful, understandable, and timely.
5. Harness Existing Data:
Identify data needs to inform priority research and policy questions; reuse data if possible and acquire additional data if needed.
6. Anticipate Future Uses:
Create data thoughtfully, considering fitness for use by others; plan for reuse and build in interoperability from the start.
7. Demonstrate Responsiveness:
Improve data collection, analysis, and dissemination with ongoing input from users and stakeholders. The feedback process is cyclical; establish a baseline, gain support, collaborate, and refine continuously. Learning Culture
8. Invest in Learning:
Promote a culture of continuous and collaborative learning with and about data through ongoing investment in data infrastructure and human resources.
9. Develop Data Leaders:
Cultivate data leadership at all levels of the federal workforce by investing in training and development about the value of data for mission, service, and the public good.
10. Practice Accountability:
Assign responsibility, audit data practices, document and learn from results, and make needed changes. 2
Draft Principles for Leveraging Data as a Strategic Asset Attachment 2 Govern and Manage Data as a Strategic Asset Principle Category Data Lifecycle Establish Data Governance Structures: Prioritize data governance within federal agencies
by establishing and supporting Data Councils/Boards to coordinate the effective 1 Ethical Governance Governance development, management, compliance, and use, and to communicate the value of data
assets.
Inventory Data Assets: Maintain an inventory of data assets with sufficient completeness, 2 Ethical Governance Governance quality, and metadata to facilitate planning, discovery, access, and use.
Identify High-Value and Authoritative Data Assets: Assign value and cost to data assets
3 based on usefulness, applicable law, regulation, policy, and operational guidance to Ethical Governance Governance appropriately prioritize and document stewardship and resource decisions. Align Resources to Value and Authority: Periodically review the alignment of resources 4 Ethical Governance Governance to the value and authority of datasets to promote consistency and fairness.
Manage High-Value and Authoritative Data Assets: Periodically review high-value and 5 authoritative data assets to identify and document opportunities to improve data Ethical Governance Governance management systems and procedures and ensure quality and integrity.
Publish Data Documentation: Publish comprehensive data documentation in publicly 6 accessible digital repositories to facilitate discovery, collaboration, access, and use, and to Conscious Design Access ensure traceability. Assess Data Maturity: Conduct and publish periodic assessments of federal dataset and 7 stewardship maturity to identify strategic opportunities to efficiently improve dataset quality Ethical Governance Governance and value.
Manage with a Long View: Include data investments in annual capital planning processes 8 and associated guidance to ensure taxpayer dollars are being used efficiently to leverage data Ethical Governance Governance as a strategic long-term asset. Coordinate Federal Data Assets: Coordinate data assets across federal agencies to fulfill 9 Ethical Governance Governance broader federal information needs and reduce collection burden.
Preserve Federal Data: Preserve federal data as a national asset by regularly reviewing the need for archiving and disposition and providing resources for preserving data in accordance Ethical Governance Disposition 10 with applicable law, regulation, policy, approved records retention or disposition schedules, and operational guidance.
Principle Category Data Lifecycle Protect and Secure Data Define Responsibilities for Protecting Confidentiality: Periodically review and revise roles and responsibilities for protecting confidential data and provide resources for training 11 Ethical Governance Governance on best practice methods to protect data in order to maintain public trust and safeguard privacy.
Review Data Releases for Disclosure Risk: Regularly conduct and periodically publish reviews of federal data released to the public to assess and minimize the risk of re12 Ethical Governance Governance identification consistent with applicable laws and policies to promote transparency and public trust.
Diversify Data Access Methods: Invest in the creation and usability of multiple tiers of
13 access to federal data by committing federal resources to making data as open and accessible Conscious Design Access as possible while protecting confidentiality. Innovate to Enable Safe Use: Explore and periodically review methods and technologies 14 that enable tiered access to safeguard data and promote accessibility to relevant Conscious Design Access stakeholders.
Prioritize Data Security: Establish priorities to weave data-centric security into every 15 Ethical Governance Governance system that is refreshed, architected, or replaced to address current and emerging threats. Evolve Data Security: Continually foster innovation in data security to ensure quality 16 Ethical Governance Governance assurance, cost savings, and security optimization.
Preserve Data Integrity: Convey data such that their veracity is knowable to users 17 Ethical Governance Governance wherever they are found.
Align Contracts with Data Management Requirements: Periodically review the terms
and conditions of contracts and other agreements involving the processing, storage, access 18 Ethical Governance Governance to, transmission, and disposition of federal data to ensure they are sufficient to meet policy
and legal requirements.
Principle Category Data Lifecycle Promote Efficient Use of Data Assets Prepare to Share: Provide encouragement and incentives for agencies to develop a culture
in which they are predisposed to share data within and across federal agencies, as well as
19 with external partners, with proper protections and where relevant and appropriate. Such a Conscious Design All culture entails not only an attitudinal shift, but a proactive effort to plan for data sharing throughout every stage of the data lifecycle. Share Data Across Agencies: Facilitate data sharing across federal agencies to efficiently 20 Conscious Design Use generate more comprehensive data for improved decision-making.
Share Data Between State and Local Governments and Federal Agencies: Facilitate
data sharing between state and local governments and the Federal Government, particularly 21 Conscious Design Use for programs which are federally-funded and locally-administered, to enable richer analyses
for more informed decision-making.
Explicitly Communicate Allowable Use: Regularly employ, and periodically review
mechanisms (such as data licenses applied to federally-hosted data) to provide clarity about
appropriate or inappropriate use, explicitly recognize any applicable intellectual property 22 Ethical Governance Create or Collect rights, convey attribution as appropriate or necessary, optimize potential value to industry, and encourage the maximum legal use of all federally-hosted data, including both protected and open data.
Leverage Buying Power: Monitor needs and systematically leverage buying power for 23 Conscious Design Create or Collect private-sector data assets and services to promote efficiency and reduce federal costs.
Connect Data Functions Across Agencies: Identify, establish, and connect a network of
offices responsible for data functions (e.g. data management, analytics, informatics, and user 24 Ethical Governance Use support) to ensure prioritization of effective management and customer service governing
the use of federal data.
Increase Staff Capacity for Data Analysis: Enhance the analytic capacity of the federal
25 workforce by investing in mechanisms to expand staff capacity in data science, program Learning Culture Use evaluation, and other analytic fields. Plan Ahead with Informed Consent: Periodically review data collection procedures for 26 opportunities to improve user understanding of potential future uses of data and promote Conscious Design Use public trust.
Principle Category Data Lifecycle Promote Efficient Use of Data Assets--Cont. Promote Wide Access: Promote fair and equitable public access to federal data through the facilitation and periodic review of many access and dissemination mechanisms and sites, 27 Conscious Design Dissemination including from both federal and non-federal providers, to maximize opportunities to use federal data.
Maximize economic value through open access: Promote open access to appropriate 28 machine-readable public data and related descriptive information to enable new economic Conscious Design Dissemination opportunities for the Nation through entrepreneurship, innovation, and scientific discovery.
Enable use through data platforms: Facilitate the collaborative use of federal data on 29 Conscious Design Use modern cloud computing platforms. Prevent Monopolization of Federal Data: Periodically evaluate and regularly monitor how 30 data are released to the public with an eye towards preventing monopolization, to ensure Ethical Governance Dissemination public data is as accessible and usable to as many members of the public as practicable.
Leverage Data Standards: Periodically review and optimize the use, adoption, and 31 creation of data standards within relevant communities of interest to identify opportunities Conscious Design Processing to maximize federal data use, access, sharing, and interoperability.
Improve Secure Data Linkage: Regularly review and adopt evolving capabilities for 32 linking data so that qualified researchers with relevant research questions can access linked Conscious Design Use data in support of national priorities and agency learning agendas.
Recover Allowable Costs: Periodically review federal data operations costs and user demand to identify cost recovery, shared service, partnership and tiered cost opportunities to support the marginal costs of dissemination, the provision of federal labor expertise, and/or 33 Ethical Governance Governance enhancement of data services to ensure taxpayer funds are appropriately and strategically invested in support of federal data.
Build a Culture that Values Data as an Asset Principle Category Data Lifecycle Promote a Culture that Values Data as an Asset: Conduct routine assessments of current 34 organizational practices to identify opportunities to improve the agency's ability to acquire, use, and disseminate data for program, statistical, and mission-support purposes to improve data use and value.
Ethical Governance All 35 36 37 Plan for Evidence-Building: Develop and publish learning agendas to strategically plan research, evaluation, and other evidence-building activities over a multi-year period. Incorporate Data into Decision-Making: As part of budget, operational, policy, and management processes, identify opportunities to effectively and routinely use data for decision-making and to create a bridge between evaluation, performance, and other activities within agencies.
Communicate Insights from Data: Adopt a range of innovative communication tools and techniques to effectively transmit insights from data to a broad set of consumers, both internal and external to the agency. Learning Culture Ethical Governance Learning Culture Use Use Use 38 Connect Federal Spending to Outcomes: Analyze spending data to align resources with strategic priorities and desired outcomes to enable the public to understand the results of federal investments and to support informed decision-making regarding future investments.
Learning Culture Use 39 Focus on End Uses of Data: Design new data collections with the end uses in mind to ensure that the data collected will be of appropriately high quality and meet internal and external stakeholder expectations and needs. Conscious Design Create or Collect
Principle Category Data Lifecycle Honor Stakeholder Input and Leverage Partners Assess the Needs of Stakeholders: Routinely engage both internal and external stakeholders throughout the data lifecycle to assess the needs of data consumers and the 40 Conscious Design All utility of existing data assets to inform action, drive impact, respond to changing customer
needs, advance innovation and commercialization, and meet the needs of the public.
Balance Stakeholder Needs: Review stakeholder feedback as part of the process for
making annual and multiyear planning, programming, budgeting, and execution decisions 41 Conscious Design All related to data stewardship and management to incorporate stakeholder needs into government priorities when appropriate and practicable.
Allow Amendment: Establish and maintain a process for members of the public to access
and amend federal data about themselves, as appropriate and in accordance with federal 42 Ethical Governance Governance laws, regulations and policies, in order to promote transparency and to help ensure the
integrity of federal data.
Monitor and Address Public Perceptions: Regularly assess public perceptions, monitoring
43 views of the value, accuracy, and objectivity of federal data to make strategic improvements Conscious Design All and ensure transparency about information policies and practices. Leverage Partnerships: Establish and periodically review public private partnerships, procurement authorities, open data practices, and workforce strategies that facilitate 44 Ethical Governance Governance collaboration and innovation with the private sector to maximize economic opportunities and intellectual value from federal data.
Engage Federal Experts: Establish and periodically review mechanisms for the sharing federal data expertise (including labor, code, and data assets) with industrial, academic, and 45 Ethical Governance Governance other data users to promote wider use of federal data and identify usability improvements to ensure federal data is serving the public interest to the maximum extent practical.
Innovate with Partners: Periodically conduct and review the results of competitions and 46 collaborations with commercial, academic, and other partners to create innovative new Conscious Design Use insights, products and services based on federal data. Honor Propriety Interests: Protect proprietary interests related to commercially-licensed 47 Ethical Governance Governance information and data to honor business investments and promote economic growth.