[PDF page 288; printed page 52730] 52730 Federal Register / Vol. 50, No. 247 / Tuesday, December 24, 1985 / Notices OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET Management of Federal Information Resources December 12,1985. agency : Office of Management and Budget, Executive Office of the President. ACTION: OMB Circular No. A-130; final publication. summary : This Circular provides a general policy framework for management of Federal information resources. The Circular implements provisions of the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1980 as well as other statutes, Executive Orders, and policies concerning general information policy, information technology, privacy, and maintenance of Federal records. The Office of Management and Budget (OMB) published a draft Circular for public comment on March 15,1985, and received comments and suggestions from the public. This'Circular supersedes OMB Circular Nos. A-71, A- 90, A-108, and A-121. date : This Circular is effective December 12,1985. FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: J. Timothy Sprehe, Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs, Room 3235 New Executive Office Building, Office of Management and Budget, Washington, D.C. 20503. Telephone: (202) 395-4814. SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The Paperwork Reduction Act of 1980, Pub. L. 96-511, 94 Stat 2812, codified at Chapter 35 of Title 44 of the United States Code, establishes a broad mandate for agencies to perform their information activities in an efficient, effective, and economical manner. Section 3504 of the Act provides authority to the Director, Office of Management and Budget (OMB), to develop and implement uniform and consistent information resources management policies; oversee the development and promote the use of information management principles, standards, and guidelines; evaluate agency information managemènt practices in order to determine their adequacy and efficiency; and determine compliance of such practices with the policies, principles, standards, and guidelines promulgated by the Director. This Circular implements OMB authority under the Paperwork Reduction Act with respect to section 3504(b), general information policy, section 3504(e), records management, section 3504(f), privacy, and section 3504(g), Federal automatic data processing and telecommunications; the Privacy Act of 1974 (5 U.S.C. 552a); sections 111 and 254 of the Federal Property and Administrative Services Act of 1949, as amended (40 U.S.C. 759); the Budget and Accounting Act of 1921 (31 U.S.C. 1 et seq.); and Executive Order No. 12046 of March 27r, 1978. The Circular complements 5 CFR Part 1320, Controlling Paperwork Burden on the Public, which implements other sections of the Paperwork Reduction Act dealing with controlling the reporting and recordkeeping burden placed on the public. In addition, the Circular revises and consolidates policy and procedures in five existing OMB directives and rescinds these directives. A-71—Responsibilities for the Administration and Management of Automatic Data Processing Activities Transmittal Memorandum No. 1 to Circular No. A-71—Security of Federal Automated Information Systems A-90—Cooperating with State and Local Governments to Coordinate and Improve Information Systems A-108—Responsibilities for the Maintenance of Records about Individuals by Federal Agencies A-121—Cost Accounting, Cost Recovery, and Interagency Sharing of Data Processing Facilities Development of the Circular On September 12,1983, OMB published a Notice in the Federal Register, 48 FR 40964, announcing development of the OMB Circular on Federal information resources management and soliciting public comment. In response to this notice, OMB received comments from 14 Federal agencies and 39 members of the public. On March 15,1985, OMB published its draft Circular on the Management of Federal Information Resources (50 FR 10734-10747), inviting the public to comment by May 14,1985. OMB informally extended the public comment period in order to allow Federal agencies and the public more time to submit their views. By August 1985, OMB had received about 350 letters of comment; 52 percent of these were from the library and academic community, 28 percent were from other members of the public, and 20 percent from Federal agencies and Members of Congress. Form of the Circular and Addition of Appendix IV The draft Circular followed the form of a notice of proposed rulemaking, which is to say that the text of the proposed Circular was accompanied by Supplementary Information containing a lengthy analysis of key sections. The analysis explained the management context and philosophy behind the language of the draft Circular. The Circular also follows the form of a notice of proposed rulemaking. Many who commented on the draft Circular requested that the explanatory contextual materials not be lost when the Circular was published in final form. OMB accepted this recommendation. Accordingly, in addition to the three appendices included in the draft Circular, OMB has added Appendix IV, Analysis of Key Sections. Appendix IV contains a revision and expansion of the analysis of key sections that accompanied the March 15 draft Circular. This Supplementary Information section focuses on comments received to the March 15 draft Circular and the disposition OMB has made of the comments. Additional Comment Because of the perceived seriousness of deficiencies in the draft Circular of March 15,1985, several commentators urged that OMB revise the draft, and issue the revision for another round of public comment. With the public notices of September 12,1983, and March 15, 1985, OMB has twice sought public comment. After analyzing public comment on the March 15 draft and revising the Circular, OMB decided not to accept this recommendation. OMB believes that the Circular as now revised accommodates valid criticisms and objections, that adequate public comment has been sought, and sees little benefit and much delay in a third round of public comment. Section-by-Section Analysis Section 1. Purpose OMB rejected a recommendation that the phrase “management of Federal information resources" be changed to “management and dissemination of Federal information resources” because the definitions of information resources management and government information already include dissemination within management. Section 3. Authorities OMB expanded the citation of the Federal Property and Administrative Services Act to include section 206 in order to reflect Federal telecommunication standards - authorities. Executive Order No. 12472, Assignment of National Security and Emergency Preparedness [PDF page 289; printed page 52731] Federal Register / Vol. 50, No. 247 / Tuesday, December 24, 1985 / Notices 52731 Telecommunications Functions, has been added to this section. Section 4. Applicability and Scope OMB revised this section to include a reference to national security and emergency preparedness telecommunications activities subject to Executive Order No. 12472. One commentator suggested that a general disclaimer be added here stating that the policies apply only where feasible, cost effective, and appropriate in the context of a particular activity. OMB rejected this suggestion because specific disclaimers are included in specific policies and because section 9a(l) assumes that heads of Federal agencies are responsible for managing their information resources in the context of particular activities and agency missions. Another commentator suggested that the Circular address which guidance will be controlling in the event of inconsistency: the Circular on national security directives. OMB does not believe such inconsistencies exist until shown in specific instances; if they should exist, they should be resolved on an individual basis. Another commentator recommended that this section should make exception for the exclusions identified in the Warner Amendment in the Department of Defense Authorization Act of 1982. OMB believes these exclusions are appropriately treated in the contexts to which they apply, and notes that statute always takes precedence over policy guidance. For clarity, OMB added an explicit reference to this Department of Defense exclusion in the definition of information technology (Section 6h). Section 6. Definitions a. Agency. Although no one commented on the definition of “agency,” OMB changed the definition because the previous wording was confusing and did not adequately convey that independent regulatory agencies are included within the meaning of the term. b. Information. One commentator noted that the definition is broader than the definition of the same term in OMB’s regulation, 5 CFR1320. The breadth of the definition is due to the fact that the scope of the Circular is broader than the scope of the regulation. Another commentator believed there were major omissions in the definition, e.g., micrographics, printing and publishing, mail and distribution, libraries, voice communications, reprographics, audiovisual, and manual information systems. OMB believes these are information media, processes, or institutions, rather than information as such, and that the definition as formulated covers them. c. Government Information. One commentator noted that the definition of “government information” does not include information that may be required to be maintained by a Federal agency, presumably as in Federal recordkeeping requirements imposed upon members of the public (e.g., individuals’ tax records). OMB does not intend that such information should be considered government information, nor does the Circular extend to such information except as specifically provided (e.g., Appendix I, Section 3a(l)). Another commentator pointed out that the definition would include information maintained by the legislative and judicial branches of government. While it is true that the definition encompasses information held by the legislative and judicial branches, the Circular applies only to agencies of the executive branch as defined in Section 6a. Another recommended that the definition of government information be restricted only to information created or collected by the Federal Government, and not be extended to information processed, transmitted, disseminated, used, stored, and disposed of by the Federal Government. OMB rejected this recommendation because 44 U.S.C. 3504 clearly applies, for example, to information processing and records management. Several commentators recommended that the definition should pertain to information “created . . . or disposed of by, or on behalf of, the Federal Government." (emphasis added) The intent of the recommendation was to make clear that the Circular’s policies applied to all information under government control or sponsorship, irrespective of the information processing agent; that is, to include all information created, collected, processed, transmitted, disseminated, used, stored, or disposed of by government contractors or grantees. OMB rejected the recommendation for several reasons. First, while agencies doubtless have the choice to treat information created or collected on their behalf as government information, OMB does not intend, except where explicitly stated, that policies in the Circular extend to persons or entities that create, collect, process, transmit, disseminate, use, store, or dispose of information on behalf of the government. Section 4 of the Circular states that the policies apply to executive agencies; Section 3a(l) of Appendix I is an explicit statement of application to Federal contracts. Second, existing and longstanding policy embodied in OMB Circular No. A-110, Uniform Administrative Requirements for Grants and Agreements with Institutions of Higher Education, Hospitals, and Other Nonprofit Organizations, permits grantees in such institutions to copyright information created or collected under Federal grants. The fact that such information may be copyrighted implies that the information is not government information, because the government may not copyright government information (17 U.S.C. 101 and 105). Third, the courts have held that requests to Federal agencies for release of information under the Freedom of Information Act do not always extend to those performing information activities under grant or contract to a Federal agency; hence, such information is not government information. Several commentators recommended that government information be subdistinguished, with special definitions being formulated for, and special policy treatment given to, scientific and technical information, statistical information, or printed information. OMB did not accept the recommendation because the Circular is intended to implement the Paperwork Reduction Act, and the Act itself does not distinguish among various kinds of information. /. andg. Access to Information and Dissemination of Information. The definitions of “access to information” and "dissemination of information,” particularly when considered together with Section 8a on information management, drew more comment than any other definitions. Twenty-three persons commented on the definitions. Commentators specially objected to the phrase “upon their request” in the definition of access. They noted that the public may gain access to government information through Freedom of Information Act requests but argued that the Circular makes no provisions to ensure the public knows what information is available or how to obtain the information. They suggested that the tone of the definitions was narrow, negative, and restrictive, and the implications ran contrary to the proper role of government in providing information in a democratic society. OMB believes that the definitions of access and dissemination, as found in the draft Circular, are sound. In OMB’s view, the commentators' objections arose not out of the definitions themselves but out of the uses to which they were put in the draft Circular’s policies and their explanation. Accordingly, OMB has made revisions [PDF page 290; printed page 52732] 52732 Federal Register / Vol. 50, No. 247 / Tuesday, December 24, 1985 / Notices to the policies and to the Analysis of Key Sections (Appendix IV), but has retained the definitions. I Information Technology Facility. Several persons pointed out the desirability of standardizing the definition of “information technology facility,” as found in the Circular and Appendix II, with “information technology installation," as found in Appendix III. The two terms are retained because they apply to different contexts, and the relationship between the terms is explained in Appendix II, Section 2b. k. Government Publication. A new term, “government publication,” has been defined because a new policy statement pertains to government publications. The definition of the term is taken directly from statute (44 U.S.C. 1901). Section 7. Basic Considerations and Assumptions 7a and 7b. These statements have been amended and broadened to reflect points raised in comments, namely, that the statements were too narrowly conceived. Deleted statement. The draft Circular contained the statement: The value of government information to the government is solely a function of the degree to which the information contributes to achieving agencies’ missions. Comments concerning this statement alleged that the statement underestimated the value of government information to the government, and failed to take account of other public needs, including those of State and local government, that are included in the value of information to the Federal Government. Because of other revisions to Section 7, OMB determined the statement was superfluous and deleted it. 7c. A new statement has been inserted in response to many comments that the draft Circular failed to address the positive aspects of government information. The statement incorporates three of the purposes of the Paperwork Reduction Act (44 U.S.C. 3501). 7d. Commentators on this statement objected to the application of cost- benefit analysis to government information activities. Many stated that the benefits of government information cannot be easily calculated and that such information holds more benefits than simply economic. Recalling that the statement is an assumption underlying policy, not itself a policy prescription, OMB notes that the statement does not preclude the existence of benefits other than economic (some of which are enumerated in statement 7b) nor does it necessarily presuppose that benefits can be easily calculated. The statement has been revised to incorporate by reference the purposes of the Paperwork Reduction Act cited in the preceding statement. Ensuring that benefits exceed costs, insofar as these are calculable, is a means to minimizing burden and costs and maximizing usefulness. 7e. Because many commentators misperceived the role accorded the private sector in the draft Circular, a new statement has been added that summarizes the existing policy found in OMB Circular No. A-76, Performance of Commercial Activities. The import of the new statement is simply that policy stated in Circular No. A-76 is and consistently has been assumed to apply to the management of Federal information resources. 7g. Several commentators believed that this statement (formerly statement 7f) did not sufficiently recognize the importance of public disclosure of government information. The statement has been revised to strengthen this point. One commentary focused on the fact that this statement pertained to the management of Federal agency records rather than management of Federal information resources. Although the Freedom of Information Act and the Privacy Act pertain only to information in agency records, the statement has been broadened, as a basic assumption, to extend to all information resources. The statement is not limited, either by intention or implication, to paper documents, but may also include electronic records. 7h. The comments on this statement (formerly statement 7g) offered suggestions already provided for in statute or policy; for example, a distinction involving statistical uses of personal information. No changes were made to the statement. 7j and 7k. These statements (formerly statements 7h and 7j) were revised to incorporate language suggested by commentators. Section 8. Policies a. Information Management. (1) and (2). Information Collection and Sharing. Many commentators believed that the formulation of 8a(l) in the draft Circular was too narrow and restrictive, that in fact the Circular would limit the collection of information by Federal agencies more than was intended by the Paperwork Reduction Act. Revised policy statement 8a(l) uses the expression “necessary for the proper performance of the functions of the agency," which is taken directly from the language of the Act (44 U.S.C. 3504 (c)(2)), and introduces a requirement for practical utility, also taken from same section of the Act. Some commentators believed the language should be couched in even broader terms, such as information needed by society or the general public. The intent of the Act, however, was to circumscribe, not to broaden, agency discretion to impose information collection and recordkeeping burdens on the public. Commentators pointed out that many statutes condition the interagency or intergovernmental sharing of information by Federal agencies. Revised policy statement 8a(2) reflects the existence of such conditions. Many also commented on the phrhse “or through commercial sources” in this statement. The revision qualifies this .phrase and Appendix IV provides further explanatory analysis of the policy. (3) through (6). Privacy Act and Freedom of Information Act. OMB revised statement 8a(3) to be consistent with statement 8a(l). Statements 8a(4)(b) and 8a(5) have been amended to eliminate ambiguity identified by commentators. (8) through (12). Information Dissemination . Statements 8a(8) and 8a(9) in the draft Circular received more comments than any other sections. First, as regards the policy that dissemination be either required by law or essential to agency missions, commentators believed these criteria were too negative and restrictive, and failed to emphasize the positive value of government information dissemination and the obligation of the government to inform the citizenry. OMB reformulated both the Circular and the analysis in Appendix IV to emphasize the government’s obligations to disseminate information, and to conform more closely to the language and intent of the Paperwork Reduction Act. Second, commentators challenged the policy that agency information products or services should not duplicate similar products or services “that could reasonably be expected to be provided' by other agencies or the private sector “in the absence of agency dissemination.” This policy was believed to be vague and impossible to apply. OMB acknowledges that “could reasonably be expected” is an inadequate formulation and has accordingly revised the policy. However, the general stricture against duplicating products or services that are or would otherwise be provided by other government or private sector organizations has been retained because the criterion of non-duplication for [PDF page 291; printed page 52733] Federal Register / Vol. 50, No. 247 / Tuesday, December 24, 1985 / Notices 52733 government information resources is clearly stated in the Act; if it is clear that an agency’s dissemination would duplicate that of a private organization, the same considerations apply. The analysis in Appendix IV has been expanded to clarify the meaning of this policy. Third, many commentators suggested that agencies provide adequate notice and opportunity for public comment before terminating information products and services. OMB believes this suggestion has merit as applied to any significant termination, and has incorporated the idea in the revised policy and Appendix IV. With respect to the non-duplication criterion, OMB added the provision that adequate notice should be provided before initiating new information products and services. This provision will allow other agencies and private sector interests to inform the initiating agency if a new product or service will duplicate their product or service, and hence satisfies the intent of the draft Circular’s language. Further explanation of this policy is also found in Appendix IV. Fourth, commentators, questioned the language in the draft Circular’s statement 8a(9)(a) requiring that agencies disseminate information products and services “in a manner that reasonably ensures the information will reach the members of the public the agency is responsible for reaching.” OMB has slightly altered the language while providing a fuller explanation in Appendix IV. Fifth, commentators challenged the language in the draft Circular’s statement 8a(9)(b) that dissemination should be accomplished "in the manner most cost effective for the government, including placing maximum feasible reliance on the private sector. . .” OMB has retained this language, but added a reference to OMB Circular No. A-76 which provides the context for the policy and conditions that address most points raised by commentators. For example, OMB Circular No. A-76 distinguishes between functions that are inherently governmental in nature, and hence should be performed by government employees, and functions that are commercial in nature and may be performed by the private sector. Again, Appendix IV contains additional discussion of the role of the private sector in disseminating government information products and services. Sixth* commentators criticized the reference to user charges in the draft Circular’s statement 8a(9)(c). OMB has retained the draft Circular’s language, because OMB Circular No. A-25 already takes account of objections raised. For example, some pointed out that the costs of assessing user charges can be greater than the revenues yielded from the charges; Circular No. A-25 provides for this contingency. Also, commentators failed to note that this policy statement requires user charges only for costs of dissemination of government information, not for creation, collection, processing, and transmission of the information. User charges also are more fully discussed in Appendix IV. Seventh, in response to comments OMB added new language requiring that agencies establish procedures for ensuring compliance with 44 U.S.C. 1902 concerning Federal depository libraries. Many commentators referenced the Federal depository library program as an existing institutional mechanism for ensuring that much government information is disseminated tcrand actually reaches the general public. They believed the Circular should strengthen the depository library system. Because OMB agreed with the comments, and since the law provides that government publications be made available to the depository libraries, OMB accepted this recommendation; the Circular requires agencies to make government publications available to the depository library system, and Appendix IV elaborates this point. b. Information Systems and Information Technology Management. (1) through (3). One commentator recommended that these policies be expanded to include a requirement that agencies document a 10 percent return on information technology investments. OMB rejected this recommendation as being too specific for inclusion in a general policy statement. (4) and (5). Several commentators recommended that these statements also include provision for cost effectiveness and meeting specific agency needs. OMB revised the policy to reflect this recommendation and also expanded on the point in Appendix IV. (6) and (7). Commentators noted that the desirability of competition is sometimes conditioned by the fact that competitive processes unnecessarily slow down procurement of information technology, and that other requirements, such as the need for compatibility, may legitimately limit competitive processes. OMB recognizes the validity of these points but believes they may be taken into account without altering the policy statements. (8). Commentators pointed out that agencies have some legitimate needs for customized software, and that acquisition of off-the-shelf software carries its own risks, such as uncertainty over continued maintenance. OMB believes that these quite meritorious considerations do not invalidate the policy statement as it stands. (9). Several commentators said that the term “interconnectivity” has specific and limited meaning in telecommunications, and that “necessary compatibility” would better convey the meaning intended. OMB revised the policy to reflect these comments and expanded on the point in Appendix IV. (14) . Commentators recommended that the background materials for this policy statement be strengthened to stress the positive values of standards and that national security directives be referenced. OMB revised Appendix IV to reflect this recommendation and the fact that the General Services Administration issues Federal Telecommunications Standards. (15) . Several agencies commented that what may be cost effective fcrir individual program managers may not be cost effective for the agency as a whole and that the policy as drafted places the burden of proof on the agency rather than the program manager. OMB recognizes the potential conflict between agency and program cost effectiveness but believes the burden of proof belongs with the agency to demonstrate that its arrangements for information technology facilities and services are the most cost effective for agency programs. One commentator recommended that agency information technology facilities be permitted to charge users market rates rather than cost recovery, because cost recovery will not be competitive with market rates. OMB’s view is that, if cost recovery is not competitive with market rates, this is prima facie evidence that agency information technology facility arrangements are not cost effective, and that program managers should be freed from mandatory use of such arrangements. (16) . Agencies commented that cost recovery systems may be expensive and should not be required where there is no clear benefit to such systems. OMB recognizes this problem and has revised Appendix II, but not the policy statement, to cover this contingency. Section 9. Assignment of Responsibilities Some commentators on this section objected to a perceived concentration in OMB of decisionmaking power over Federal information resources, believing that the Circular places program decisions in OMB's hands. OMB notes first that the Paperwork Reduction Act [PDF page 292; printed page 52734] 52734 Federal Register / Vol. 50, No. 247 / Tuesday, December 24, 1985 / Notices requires the director of OMB to develop and implement Federal information policies, principles, standards, and guidelines (44 U,S,C. 3504). Second, the Circular states, and Appendix IV emphasizes, that program decisionmaking for Federal information resources belongs with the heads of agencies, operating within the policy framework set forth by OMB. Several commentators recommended that this section include a statement concerning the Federal depository libraries. OMB believes the addition of statement 8a(12)(b) regarding the depository libraries covers this recommendation. Also, OMB did not accept a commentator’s recommendation that certain responsibilities be assigned to Federal libraries; such libraries are subunits of agencies and the Circular assigns responsibilities only at the agency level. Several commentators recommended that OMB assign responsibility for the Office of Personnel Management to develop and implement occupational and position standards for information resources managers. OMB does not believe management of Federal information resources requires establishing new job titles and series. Furthermore, such establishment would require legislation and could not be legally accomplished through an OMB Circular. Several Federal agencies requested that various statements assigning responsibilities be revised to include reference to their statutory or regulatory responsibilities. OMB reviewed these requests and determined that revisions were unnecessary. The Circular presupposes the existence of, and compliance with, other applicable laws and regulations. a(6). In response to comments OMB revised thia statement more accurately to reflect agency responsibilities for Federal records management. a(9). OMB inserted a reference to convey that the “senior official’’ is identical to the provision of 44 U.S.C. 3506(b). b(l). At the suggestion of a commentator, OMB substituted “information resources management policy” for “information policy" because the latter term is not defined or used elsewhere in the Circular. e(4). One commentator noted that assigning GSA responsibility for providing guidelines and regulations on the use of information technology contravenes the Brooks Act (40 U.S.C. 759(g)). OMB revised the statement to reflect this point. h(12). OMB revised the statement in the Same manner as statement 9b(l). Appendix I Several commentators expressed concern that promulgation of the appendix would rescind the OMB “Guidelines on Implementing the Privacy Act," and other suggested combining the appendix with all guidance OMB has issued on the Act. OMB did not intend to replace existing guidance with the appendix. The appendix replaces only the procedural requirements contained in OMB Circular No. A-108. All other guidance remains in force, and OMB has revised the appendix to make that clear. OMB declined to follow the suggestion that the appendix and other guidance be combined, because the purposes of each issuance are different. Other commentators pointed out inconsistencies in the timing of various reviews required by the Circular’s different appendices; suggested clarifying by examples what constitutes a “minor change to a system of records”; suggested changing the timing of the review of section (m) contracts to more frequently than every five years, since review is conducted on a random sample basis and should not prove overly burdensome; and suggested that the first triennial review of routine uses be commenced immediately upon issuance of the Circular. OMB revised the appendix to reflect these comments. OMB revised the appendix to reflect these comments. OMB added a requirement for an annual review of all systems notices; added certain data collection requirements for the annual report pursuant to section (p); and dropped a requirement for the Office of the Federal Register to provide OMB with a consolidated list of changes to agencies’ systems of records. Appendix II Several commentators expressed concern about the cost effectiveness of requiring detailed accounting and chargeback fof use of relatively small information technology facilities. OMB agreed with these comments. The intent of Appendix II is to encourage cost effective behavior in the management of Federal information technology resources. In revising the Appendix OMB raised the threshold so that the Appendix applies only to facilities having obligations in excess of $3 million per year. A number of commentators pointed out that the Appendix does not allow facilities to justify resource requests based upon sharing, except in unusual circumstances. OMB revised the Appendix to clarify that this restriction is included because the normal practice is for users of a facility to include resource requests for the amount of technology use in their budget and appropriation requests. Several commentators believed that requiring full costs to be recovered from all users within ail agency would not be cost effective. OMB disagreed with this viewpoint and retained the draft Circular’s formulation. Viable management of a large information technology facility requires that managers know the amount of resources devoted to each user when providing services. Furthermore, effective management of the use of information technology requires that the user have responsibility for and control Qver the resources Consumed by use of the facility. Finally, a number of commentators questioned the advisability of giving users of significant new applications primary responsibility for selecting which facility will support the applications. OMB disagreed and retained the draft Circular’s formulation. When users are dependent on effective technology support to perform their function, control over selection of facility is essential and consistent with holding users responsible for producing their government information products. Appendix III Several commentators asked for clarification of the relationship between Appendix III and OMB Circular No. A- 123. The Appendix itself relates certain of its requirements to requirements in Circular No. A-123 (e.g., annual reporting of security weaknesses as material weaknesses, and a separate assurance of the security of agency automated information systems in the annual internal control report required by Circular No. A-123). Beyond these specific requirements, application controls specified in the Appendix should be verified in vulnerability assessments and internal control reviews of the functional area supported by the application. Installation controls specified in the Appendix should be reviewed as one of the generic controls of an information technology unit itself. Several commentators asked hoW the Circular relates to OMB Circular No. A- 127, Financial Management Systems. The evaluation and reporting requirements for the systems integrity objective contained in OMB Circular No. A-127 may be met by fulfilling the evaluation and reporting requirements contained in Appendix III to this Circular and in OMB Circular No. A- 123. [PDF page 293; printed page 52735] Federal Register / Vol. 50, No. 247 / Tuesday, December 24, 1985 / Notices 52735W Hll' 'W W M Several commentators also expressed confusion about the relation between Appendix III and security of national security information. OMB revised Appendix III to clarify that the Appendix provides a minimal set of requirements for the security of Federal automated information systems; required agencies to also incorporate additional requirements for security of information classified, for national security purposes; and clarified central agency responsibilities related to national security information. Several commentators suggested that Appendix III use the term “information technology facility” for consistency with the Circular and Appendix II. The term “information technology installation,” as used in Appendix III, includes information technology facilities as well as small localized processing capabilities. OMB retained the term "information technology installation” in order to emphasize the importance of assuring adequate security of such smaller systems as well as of larger facilities. OMB expects that management processes for assuring a proper level of security at small installations will be less detailed and resource intensive than at larger facilities. Several commentators expressed concern that personnel security responsibilities in the Appendix focused only on screening employees. They pointed out that pther personnel activities, such as separation of duties and actions relating to employees leaving an agency, may be more cost effective security measures. OMB agreed with these comments and clarified the language concerning agency personnel programs so as not to limit agency personnel programs to employment screening of personnel, while still requiring employment screening as one tool in agency security programs. Circular No. A-130 To the Heads of Executive Departments and Establishments December 12,1985. Subject: Management Of Federal Information Resources 1. Purpose: This Circular establishes policy for the management of Federal information resources. Procedural and analytic guidelines for implementing specific aspects of these policies are included as appendices. 2. Rescissions: This Circular rescinds OMB Circulars No. A-71, A-90, A-108, and A-121, and ail Transmittal Memoranda to those circulars. 3. Authorities: This Circular is issued pursuant to the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1980 {44 U.S.C. 35); the Privacy Act of 1974 (5 U.S.C. 552a), sections 111 and 206 of the Federal Property and Administrative Services Act of 1949 as amended (40 U.S.C. 759 and 487, respectively), the Budget and Accounting Act of 1921 as amended (31 U.S.C. 11), Executive Order No. 12046 of March 27,1978, and Executive Order No. 12472 of April 3,1984. 4. Applicability and Scope: a. The policies in this Circular apply to the information activities of all agencies of the executive branch of the Federal Government. b. Information classified for national security purposes should also be handled in accordance with the appropriate national security directives. National security emergency - preparedness activities should be conducted in accordance with Executive Order No. 12472. 5. Background: The Paperwork Reduction Act establishes a broad mandate for agencies to perform their information management activities in an efficient, effective, and economical manner. To assist agencies in an integrated approach to information resources management, the Act requires that the Director of the Office of Management and Budget (OMB|) develop and implement uniform and consistent information resources management policies; oversee the development and promote the use of information management principles, standards, and guidelines; evaluate agency information management practices in order to determine their adequacy and efficiency; and determine compliance of such practices with the policies, principles, standards, and guidelines promulgated by the Director. 6. Definitions: As used in this Circular— a. The term “agency” means any executive department, military department, government corporation, government controlled corporation, or other establishment in the executive branch of the government, or any independent regulatory agency. Within the Executive Office of the President, ■ the term includes only the Office of Management and Budget and the Office of Administration. b. The term “information” means any communication or reception of knowledge such as facts, data, or opinions, including numerical, graphic, or narrative forms, whether, oral or maintained in any medium, including computerized data bases, paper, microform, or magnetic tape. C. The term “government information” means information created, collected, processed, transmitted, disseminated, used, stored, or disposed of by the Federal Government. d. The term “information system” means the organized collection, processing, transmission, and dissemination of information in accordance with defined procedures, whether automated or manual. e. The term “major information system” means an information system that requires special continuing management attention because of its importance to an agency mission; its high development, operating or maintenance costs; or its significant impact on the administration of agency programs, finances, property, or other resources. f. The term “access to information” refers to the function of providing to members of the public, upon their request, the government information to which they are entitled under law. g. The term “dissemination of information” refers to the function of distributing government information to the public, whether through printed documents, or electronic or other media. "Dissemination of information” does not include intra-agency use of information, interagency sharing of information, or - responding to requests for “access to information.” h. The term “information technology” , means the hardware and software used in connection with government information, regardless of the technology involved, whether computers, telecommunications, micrographics, or others. For the purposes of this Circular, automatic data processing and telecommunications activities related to certain critical national security missions, as defined in 44 U.S.C. 3502(2) and 10 U.S.C. 2315, are excluded. i. The term “information technology facility” means an organizationally defined set of personnel, hardware, software, and physical facilities, a primary function of which is the operation of information technology. j. The term “information resources management” means the planning, budget, organizing, directing, training, and control associated with government information. The term encompasses both information itself and the related resources, such as personnel, equipment, funds, and technology. k. The term “government publication” means informational matter which is published as an individual document at government expense, or as required by law. • [PDF page 294; printed page 52736] Federal Register / Vol. 50, No. 247 / Tuesday, December 24, 1985 / Notices52736 Other definitions specific to the subjects of the appendices appear in the appendices. 7. Basic Considerations and Assumptions: a. The Federal Government is the largest Single producer, consumer, and disseminator of information in the United States. Because of the sizebf the government’s information activities, the dependence of government information activities upon the public’s cooperation, and the value of government information to the entire Nation, the management of Federal information resources is an issue of continuing importance to the public and to the government itself. b. Government information is a valuable national resource. It provides citizens with knowledge of their government, society, and economy— past, present, and future; is a means to ensure the accountability of government; is vital to the healthy performance of the economy; is an essential tool for managing the government’s operations; and is itself a commodity often with economic value in the marketplace. c. The free flow of information from the government to its citizens and vice versa is essential to a democratic society. It is also essential that the government minimize the Federal paperwork burden on the public, minimize the cost of its information activities, the maximize the usefulness of government information. d. In order to minimize the cost and maximize the usefulness of government information activities, thé expected public and private benefits derived from government information, insofar as they are calculable, should exceed the public and private costs of the information. e. Although certain functions are ■ inherently governmental in nature, being so intimately related to the public interest as to mandate performance by Federal employees, the government should look first to private sources, where available, to provide the commercial goods and services needed by the government to act on the public’s behalf, particularly when cost comparisons indicate that private performance will be the most economical. f. The use of up-to-date information technology offers opportunities to improve the management of government programs, and access to, and dissemination of, government information. g. Because the public disclosure of government information is essential to the operation of a democracy, the public’s right to access to government information must be protected in the management of Federal information resources, h. The individual’s right to privacy must be protected iii Federal Government information activities involving personal information. i. The open and efficient exchange of government scientific and technical information, subject to applicable national security controls and proprietary rights others may have in- such information, fosters excellence in scientific research and the effective use of Federal research and development funds. j. The value of preserving government records is a function of the degree to which preservation protects the legal and financial rights of the government or its citizens, and provides an official record of Federal agency activities for agency management, public accountability, and historical purposes. k. Federal Government information resources management policies and activities can affect, and be affected by, the information policies and activities of other nations. 8. Policies: a. Information Management. Agencies shall: (1) Create or collect only that informtion necessary for the proper performance of agency functions and that has practical utility, and only after planning for its processing, transmission, dissemination, use, storage, and disposition; (2) Seek to satisfy new information needs through legally authorized interagency or intergovernmental sharing of information, or through commercial sources, where appropriate, before creating or collecting new information; (3) Limit the collection of individually «identifiable information and proprietary information to that which is legally authorized and necessary for the proper performance of agency functions; (4) Maintain and protect individually identifiable information and proprietary information in a manner that precludes: (a] Unwarranted intrusion upon personal privacy (see Appendix I); and (b) Violation of confidentiality; (5) Provide individuals with access to, and the ability to amend errors in, systems of records, consistent with the Privacy Act; (6) Provide public access to government information, consistent with the Freedom of Information Act; (7) Ensure that agency personnel are trained to safeguard information resources; (8) Disseminate information, as required by law, describing agency organization, activities, programs, meetings, systems of records, and other information holdings, and how the public may gain access to agency information resources; (9) Disseminate such information products and services as are: (a) Specifically required by law; or (b) Necessary for the proper performance of agency functions, provided that the latter do not duplicate similar products or services that are or would otherwise be provided by other government or private sector organizations; (10) Disseminate significant new, or terminate significant existing, information products and services only after providing adequate notice to the public; (11) Disseminate such government information products and services: (a) In a manner that ensures that members of the public whom the agency has an obligation to reach have a reasonable ability to acquire the information; (b) In the manner most cost effective for the government, including placing maximum feasible reliance on the private sector for the dissemination of the products or services in accordance with OMB Circular No. A-76; and (c) So as to recover costs of disseminating the products or services through user charges, where appropriate, in accordance with OMB Circular No. A-25; (12) Establish procedures for: (a) Reviewing periodically the continued need for and manner of dissemination of the agency’s information products or services; and (b) Ensuring that government publications are made available to depository libraries as required by law. b. Information Systems and Information Technology Management Agencies shall: (1) Establish multiyear strategic planning processes for acquiring and operating information technology that meet program and mission needs, reflect budget constraints, and form the bases for their budget requests; (2) Establish systems of management control that document the requirements that each major information system is intended to serve; and provide for periodic review of those requirements over the life of the system in order to determine whether the requirements continue to exist and the system continues to meet the purposes for which it was developed; (3) Make the official whose program an information system supports responsible and accountable for the products of that system; [PDF page 295; printed page 52737] Federal Register / Vol, 50, No. 247 / Tuesday, December T i w r i n r i i r n m T r i r i r T r m - ^ i B | - i B r r i i w M i r i B i [ M r i mi y a iia iiL (4) Meeting information processing needs through interagency sharing and from commercial sources, when it is cost effective, before acquiring new information processing capacity; (5) Share available information processing capacity with other agencies to the extent practicable and legally permissible; (6) Acquire information technology in a competitive manner that minimizes total life cycle costs; (7) Ensure that existing and planned major information systems do not unnecessarily duplicate information systems available from other agencies or from the private sector; (8) Acquire off-the-shelf software from commercial sources, unless the cost effectiveness of developing custom 'software is clear and has been documented; (9) Acquire or develop information systems in a manner that facilitates necessary compatibility; (10) Assure that information systems operate effectively and accurately; (11) Establish a level of security for all agency information systems commensurate with the sensitivity of the information and the risk and magnitude of loss or harm that could result from improper operation of the information systems (See Appendix III); (12) Assure that only authorized - personnel have access to information systems; (13) Plan to provide information systems with reasonable continuity of support should their normal operations be disrupted in an emergency; (14) Use Federal Information Processing and Telecommunications Standards except where it can be demonstrated that the costs of using a standard exceed the benefits or the standard will impede the agency in accomplishing its mission; (15) Not require program managers to use specific information technology facilities or services unless it is clear and is convincingly documented, subject to periodic review, that such use is the most cost effective method for meeting program requirements; (16) Account for the full costs of operating information technology facilities and recover such costs from government users as provided in Appendix II; (17) Not prescribe Federal information system requirements that unduly restrict the prerogatives of heads of State and local government units; (18) Seek opportunities to improve the operation of government programs or to realize savings for the government and the public through the application of up- to-date information technology to government information activities. 9. Assignment- of Responsibilities: a. All Federal Agencies. The head of each agency shall: (1) Have primary responsibility for managing agency information resources; (2) Ensure that the information policies, principles, standards, guidelines, rules, and regulations prescribed by OMB are implemented appropriately within the agency; (3) Develop internal agency information policies and procedures and oversee, evaluate, and otherwise periodically review agency information resources management activities for conformity with the policies set forth in this Circular; (4) Develop agency policies and procedures that provide for timely acquisition of required information technology; (5) Maintain an inventory of the agencies’ major information systems and information dissemination programs; (6) Create, maintain, and dispose of a record of agency activities in accordance with the Federal Records Act of 1950, as amended; (7) Identify to the Director, OMB statutory, regulatory, and other impediments to efficient management of Federal information resources and recommend to the Director legislation, policies, procedures, and other guidance to improve such management; (8) Assist OMB in the performance of its functions under the Paperwork Reduction Act, including making services, personnel, and facilities available to OMB for this purpose to the extent practicable; (9) Appoint a senior official, as required by 44 U.S.C. 3506(b), who shall report directly to the agency head, to carry out the responsibilities of the agency under the Paperwork Reduction Act. The head of the agency shall keep the Director, OMB, advised as to the name, title, authority, responsibilities, ; and organizational resources of the senior official. For purposes of this paragraph military departments and the Office of the Secretary of Defense may each appoint one official. b. Department of State. The Secretary of State shall: (1) Advise the Director, OMB, on the development of United States positions and policies on international information policy issues affecting Federal Government information activities and ensure that such positions and policies are consistent with Federal information resources management policy; 24, 1985 / Notices 52737 (2) Ensure, in consultation with the Secretary of Commerce, that the United States is represented in the development of international information technology standards, and advise the Director, OMB, of such activities. c. Department of Commerce. The Secretary of Commerce shall: (1) Develop and issue Federal Information Processing Standards and guidelines necessary to ensure the efficient and effective acquisition, management, security, and use of information technology; (2) Advise the Director, OMB, on the development of policies relating to the procurement and management of Federal telecommunications resources; (3) Provide OMB and the agencies with scientific and technical advisory services relating to the development and use of information technology; (4) Conduct studies and evaluations concerning telecommunications technology, and concerning the improvement, expansion, testing, operation, and use of Federal telecommunications systems and advise the Director, OMB, and appropriate agencies of the recommendations that result from such studies; (5) Develop, in consultation with the Secretary of State and the Director, OMB, plans, policies, and programs relating to international telecommunications issues affecting government information activities; (6) Identify needs for standardization of telecommunications and information processing technology, and develop standards, in consultation with the Secretary of Defense and the Administrator of General Sërvcies, to ensure efficient application of such technology; (7) Ensure that the Federal Govemment is represented in the development of national and, in consultation with the Secretary of State, international information technology standards, and advise the Director, OMB, of such activities. d. Department of Defense. The Secretary of Defense shall develop, in consultation with the Administrator of General Services, uniform Federal telecommunications standards and guidelines to ensure national security, emergency preparedness, and continuity of government. e. General Services Administration. The Administrator of General Services shall: (1) Advise the Director, OMB, and agency heads on matters affecting the procurement of information technology; (2) Coordinate and, when required, provide for the purchase, lease, and [PDF page 296; printed page 52738] 52738 Federal Register / maintenance of information technology required by Federal agencies; (3) Develop criteria for timely procurement of information technology and delegate procurement authority to agencies that comply with the criteria; (4) Provide guidelines and regulations for Federal agencies, as authorized by law, on the acquisition, maintenance, and disposition of information technology; (5) Develop policies and guidelines that facilitate the sharing of information technology among agencies as requried by this Circular; (6) Review agencies’ information resources management activities to meet the objectives of the triennial reviews required by the Paperwork Reduction Act and report the results to the Director, OMB; (7) Manage the Automatic Data Processing Fund and the Federal Telecommunications Fund in accordance with the Federal Property and Administrative Services Act, as amended; (8) Establish procedures For approval, implementation, and dissemination of Federal telecommunications standards and guidelines and for implementation of Federal Information Processing Standards. f. Office of Personnel Management. The Director, Office of Personnel Management, shall; (1) Develop and conduct training programs for Federal personnel on information resources management, including end user computing; (2) Evaluate periodically future personnel management and staffing requirements for Federal information resources management; (3) Establish personnel security policies and develop training programs for Federal personnel associated with the disgn, operation, or maintenance of information systems. - g. National Archives and Records Administration. The Archivist of the United States shall: (1) Administer the Federal records management program in accordance with the National Archives and Records Act; (2) Assist the Director, OMB, in developing standards and guidelines relating to the records management program, h. Office of Management and Budget The Director of the Office of Management and Budget shall: (1) Provide overall leadership and coordination of Federal information resources management within the executive branch; (2) Serve as the President’s principal adviser on procurement and Voi. 50, No. 247 / Tuesday, December management of Federal telecommunications systems, and develop and establish policies for procurement and management of such systems; (3) Issue policies, procedures, and guidelines to assist agencies in achieving integrated, effective, and efficient information resources management; (4) Initiate and review proposals for changes in legislation, regulations, and agency procedures to improve Federal information resources management; (5) Review and approve or disapprove agency proposals for collection of information from the public, as defined in 5 CFR 1320.7; (6) Develop and publish annually, in consultation with the Administrator of General Services, a five-year plan for meeting the information technology needs of the Federal government; (7) Evaluate agencies’ information resources management and identify cross-cutting information policy issues through the review of agency information programs, information collection budgets, information technology acquisition plans, fiscal budgets, and by other means; (8) Provide policy oversight for the Federal records management function conducted by the National Archives and Records Administration and coordinate records management policies and programs with other information activities; (9) Review, with the advice and assistance of the Administrator of General Services, selected agencies" information resources management activities to meet the objectives of the triennial reviews required by the Paperwork Reduction Act; (10) Review agencies’ policies, practices, and programs pertaining to the security, protection, sharing, and disclosure of information, in order to ensure compliance with the Privacy Act and related statutes; (11) Resolve information technology procurement disputes between agencies and the General Services Administration pursuant to Section 111 of the Federal Property and Administrative Services Act; (12) Review proposed U.S. government position and policy statements on international issues affecting Federal Government information activities and advise the Secretary of State as to their consistency with Federal information resources management policy. 10. Oversight, the Director, OMB, will use information technology planning reviews, fiscal budget reviews, information collection budget reviews. 24, 1985 / Notices management reviews, GSA reviews of agency information resources management activities, and such other measures as he deems necessary to evaluate the adequacy and efficiency of each agency’s information resources management and compliance with this Circular. 11. Effective Date. This Circular is effective upon publication (December 12,1985). 12. Inquiries. All questions or inquiries should be addressed to Office of Information and Regulatory' Affairs, Office of Management and Budget, Washington, D.C. 20503. Telephone: (202) 395-3287. 13. Sunset Review Date. This Circular shall have an Independent policy review to ascertain its effectiveness three years from the date of issuance. James G. Miller III, Director. Appendix I: Federal Agency Responsibilities for Maintaining Records about Individuals Appendix II: Cost Accounting, Cost Recovery, and Interagency Sharing of Information Technology Facilities Appendix III: Security of Federal Automated Information System s Appendix IV: A nalysis of Key Sections Darrell A. Johnson, Assistant Director for Administration. Appendix I to OMB Circular No. A- 130—Federal Agency Responsibilities for Maintaining Records About Individuals 1. Purpose and Scope. This Appendix describes agency responsibilities for implementing the Privacy Act of 1974, 5 U.S.C. 552a as amended (hereinafter “the Act’’). It applies to all agencies subject to the Act. The Appendix constitutes a revision to procedures formerly contained in OMB Circular No. A-108, now rescinded. Note that this Appendix does not rescind other guidance OMB has issued to help agencies interpret the Privacy Act's provisions, e.g., Privacy Act Guidelines (40 FR 28949-28978, July 9,1975), or Guidance for Conducting Matching Programs (47 FR 21656-21658. May 19,1982). 2. Definitions. a. The terms “agency,” "individual," "maintain,” “record,” “system of records,” and “routine use,” as used in this Appendix, are defined in the Act (5 U.S.C. 552a(a)). The definition of “agency” in the Act differs somewhat from the definition in the Circular. b. The term “minor change to a system of records” means a change that does not significantly change the system: that is. does not affect the character or [PDF page 297; printed page 52739] Federal Register / Vol. 50, No. 247 / Tuesday, December 24, 1985 / Notices 52739 purpose of the system and does not affect the ability of an individual to gain access to his or her record or to any information pertaining to him or her which is contained in the system; e.g., changing the title of the system manager. 3. Assignment of Responsibilities. a. All Federal Agencies. In addition to meeting the agency requirements contained in the Act, and the specific reporting requirements detailed in this Appendix, the head of each agency shall ensure that the following reviews are conducted as often as specified below, and be prepared to report to the Director, OMB, the Tesults of such reviews and the corrective action taken to resolve problems uncovered. The head of each agency shall: (1) Section (m) Contracts. Review every two years a random sample of agency contracts that provide for the maintenance of a system of records on behalf of the agency to accomplish an agency function, in order to ensure that the wording of each contract makes the provisions of the Act apply. (5 LJ.S.C. 552a(m)(l)) (2) Recordkeeping Practices. Review annually agency recordkeeping and disposal policies and practices in order to assure compliance with the Act. (3) Routine Use Disclosures. Review every three years the routine use disclosures associated with each system of records in order to ensure that the recipient’s use of such records continues to be compatible with the purpose for which the disclosing agency originally collected the information. The first such review should commence immediately upon the issuance of this Appendix. (4) Exemption of Systems of Records. Review every three years each system of records for which the agency has promulgated exemption rules pursuant to Section (j) or (k] of the Privacy Act in order to determine whether such exemption is still needed. (5) Matching Programs. Review annually each ongoing matching program in which the agency has participated during the year, either as a source or as a matching agency, in order to ensure that the requirements of the Act, the OMB Matching Guidelines, and the OMB Model Control System and Checklist have been met. (6) Privacy Act Training. Review annually agency training practices in order to ensure that all agency personnel are familiar with the requirements of the Act, with the agency’s implementing regulation, and with any special requirements that their specific jobs entail. (7) Violations. Review annually the actions of agency personnel that have resulted either in the agency being found civilly liable under Section (g) of the Act, or an employee being found criminally liable under the provisions of Section (i) of the Act, in order to determine the extent of the problem and to find the most effective way to prevent recurrences of the problem. (8) Systems of Records Notices. Review annually each system of records notice to ensure that it accurately describes the system. Where minor changes are needed, ensure that an amended notice is published in the Federal Register. Agencies may choose to make one annual comprehensive publication consolidating such minor changes. This requirement is distinguished from and in addition to the requirement to report to OMB and the Congress major changes to systems of records and to publish those changes in the Federal Register (see paragraph 4b of this Appendix). b. Department of Commerce. The Secretary of Commerce shall, consistent with guidelines issued by the Director, OMB, develop and issue standards and guidelines for assuring the security of information protected by the Privacy Act in automated information systems. c. General Services Administration. The Administrator of General Services shall, consistent with guidelines issued by the Director, OMB, issue instructions on what agencies must do in order to comply with the requirements of Section (m) of the Act when contracting for the operation of a system of records to accomplish an agency purpose. d. Office of Personnel Management. The Director of the Office of Personnel Management shall, consistent with guidelines issued by the Director, OMB; (1) Develop and maintain government- wide standards and procedures for civilian personnel information processing and recordkeeping directives to assure conformance with the Act. (2) Develop and conduct training programs for agency personnel, including both the conduct of courses in various substantive areas (e g., legal, administrative, information technology) and the development of materials that agencies can use in their own courses. The assignment of this responsibility to OPM does not affect the responsibility of individual agency heads for developing and conducting training programs tailored to the specific needs of their own personnel. e. National Archives and Records Administration. The Archivist of the United States shall, consistent with guidelines issued by the Director, OMB: (1) Issue instructions on the format of the Agency notices and rules required to be published under the Act. (2) Compile and publish annually the rules promulgated under 5 U.S.C. 552a(f) and agency notices published under 5 U.S.C 552a(e)(4) in a form available to the public. (3) Issue procedures governing the transfer or records to Federal Records Centers for storage, processing, and servicing pursuant to 44 U.S.C. 3103. For purposes of the Act, such records are considered to be maintained by the agency that deposited them. The Archivist may disclose deposited records only according to the access rules established by the agency that deposited them. f. Office of Management and Budget The Director of the Office of Management and Budget will: (1) Issue guidelines and directives to the agencies to implement the Act. (2) Assist the agencies, at their request, in implementing their Privacy Act programs. (3) Review the new and altered system reports agencies submit pursuant to Section (o) of the Act. (4) Compile the annual report of the President to the Congress in accordance with Section (p) of the Act. 4. Reporting Requirements. a. Privacy Act Annual Reports. To provide the necessary information for the annual report of die President, agencies shall submit a Privacy Act Annual Report to the Director, OMB, covering their Privacy Act activities for the calendar year, The exact format and timing of the report will be established by the Director, OMB. (5 U.S.C. 552a(p)); but, agencies should, at a minimum collect, and be prepared to report the following data on a calendar year basis: (1) Total number of active systems of records and changes to that population during the year, e.g., publications of new systems, additions and deletions of routine uses, exemptions, automation of record systems. (2) Public comments received on agency publications and implementation activities. (3) Number of requests from individuals for access to records about themselves in systems of records that cited the Privacy Act in support of their requests. (4) Number granted in whole or part, denied in whole, and for which no record was found. (5) Number of amendment requests from individuals to amend records about them in systems of records that cited the Privacy Act in support of their requests. (6) Number granted in whole or part, denied in whole, and for which no record was found. [PDF page 298; printed page 52740] 52740 Federal Register / Vol. 50, No. 247 / Tuesday, December 24, 1985 / Notices (7) Number of appeals of access and amendment denials and the results of such appeals. (8) Number of instances in which individuals litigated the results of appeals of access or amendment, and the results of such litigation. (9) Number and description of matching programs participated in either as source or matching agency. b. New and Altered System Reports. The Act requires agencies to publish notices in the Federal Register describing new or altered systems of records, and to submit reports on these systems to the Director, OMB, and to the Congress. (1) Altered System of Records. Minor changes to systems of records need not be reported. For example, a change in the designation of the system manager due to a reorganization would not require a report, so long as an individual's ability to gain access to his or her records is not affected. Other examples include changing applicable safeguards as a result of a risk analysis, deleting a routine use when there is no longer a need for the authorized disclosure. These examples are not intended to be all-inclusive. The following changes are those for which a report is required; (a) An increase or change in the number or types of individuals on whom records are maintained. For example, a decision to expand a system that originally covered only residents of public housing in major cities to cover such residents nationwide would require a report. Increases attributable to normal growth should not be reported. (b) A change that expands the types or categories of information maintained. For example, « personnel file that has been expanded to include medical records would require a report. (c) A change that alters the purpose for which the information is used. (d) A change to equipment configuration (either hardware or software) that creates substantially greater access to the records in the system. For example, locating interactive terminals at regional offices for accessing a system formerly accessible only at the headquarters would require a report. (e) The addition of an exemption (pursuant to Section (j) or (k) of the Act). Note that, in submitting a rulemaking for an exemption as part of a report of a new or altered system, agencies will meet the reporting requirements of Executive Order No. 12291 and need not make a separate submission under that order. When an agency makes a change to an information technology installation, telecommunication network, or any other general changes in information collection, processing, dissemination, or storage that affect multiple systems of records, it may submit a single consolidated new or altered system report, with changes to existing notices and supporting documentation included in the submission. (2) Contents of the Report The report for a new or altered system has three elements: a transmittal letter, a narrative statement, and supporting documentation that includes a copy of the proposed Federal Register notice. There is no prescribed format for either the letter or the narrative statement. The notice must appear in the format prescribed by the Office of the Federal Register’s Document Drafting Handbook. (a) Transmittal Letter. The transmittal letter shoud be signed by the senior agency official responsible for implementation of the Act within the agency and should contain the name and telephone number of the individual who can best answer questions about the system. The letter should contain the agency’s assurance that the proposed system does not duplicate any existing agency systems. It should also state that a copy of the report has been distributed to the Speaker of the House and the President of the Senate as the Act requires. The letter may also include requests for waiver of the reporting time period. (b) Narrative Statement. The narrative statement should be brief. It should make reference, as appropriate, to information in the supporting documentation rather than restating such information. The statement should: (7) Describe the purpose for which the agency is establishing the system of records. (2) Identify the authority under which the system is maintained. The agency should avoid citing housekeeping statutes, but rather cite the underlying programmatic authority for collecting, maintaining, and using the information. When the system is being operated to support an agency housekeeping program, e.g., a carpool locator, the agency may, however, cite a general housekeeping statute that authorizes the agency head to keep such records as are necessary. (5) Provide the agency’s evaluation of the probable or potential effects of the proposal on the privacy of individuals. (4) Describe the relationship of the proposal, if any, to the other branches of the Federal Government and to State and local governments. (5) Provide a brief description of the steps taken by the agency to minimize the risk of unauthorized access to the system of records. A more detailed assessment of the risks and specific administrative, technical, procedural, and physical safeguards established shall be made available to OMB upon request. (6) Explain how each proposed routine use satisfies the compatibility requirement of subsection (a)(7) of the Act. For altered systems, this requirement pertains only to any newly proposed routine uses. (7) Provide OMB control numbers, expiration dates, and titles of any OMB approved information collection requirements contained in the system of records. If the request for OMB clearance of an information collection is pending, the agency may simply state the title of the collection and the date it was submitted for OMB clearance. (c) Supporting Documentation. Attach the following to all new or altered system reports: f1) An advance copy of the new or altered system notice (consistent with the provisions of 5 U.S.C. 552a(e)(4)) that the agency proposes to publish for the new or altered system. For proposed altered systems the documentation should be in the same form as the agency proposes to publish in the public notice. (2) An advance copy of any new rules or changes to published rules (consistent with the provision of 5 U.S.C. 552a (f), (j), and (k)) that the agency proposes to issue for the new or altered system. If no changes to existing rules are required, the agency shall so state in the narrative portion of the report. Proposed changes to existing rules shall be provided in the same form as the agency proposes to publish for formal notice and comment. (3) Timing and Distribution for Submitting New and Altered System Reports. Submit reports on new and altered systems of records not later than 60 days prior to establishment of a new system or the implementation of an altered system (5 U.S.C. 552a(o)). Submit three copies of each report to: President of the Senate, Washington. D.C. 20510 Speaker of the House of Representatives, Washington, D.C. 20515 Administrator, Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs, Office of Management and Budget, Washington, D.C. 20503. Agencies may assume that OMB concurs in Privacy Act aspects of their proposal if OMB has not commented [PDF page 299; printed page 52741] Federal Register / Vol. 50, No. 247 / Tuesday, December 24, 1985 / Notices 52741 within 60 days from the date the transmittal letter was signed. Agencies may publish system and routine use notices as well as exemption rules in the Federal Register at the same time that they send the new or altered system report to OMB and the Congress. The 60- day period for OMB and Congressional review and the 30-day notice and comment period for routine uses and exemptions will then run concurrently. (4) Waivers o f Report Time Period. The Director, OMB, may grant a waiver of the 60-day period if the agency asks for the waiver and can demonstrate compelling reasons. Agencies may assume that OMB concurs in their request if OMB has not commented within 30 days of the date the transmittal letter was signed. When a waiver is granted, the agency is not thereby relieved of any other responsibility or liability under the Act. Note that OMB cannot waive time periods specifically established by the Act Agencies will still have to meet the statutory notice and comment periods required for establishing a routine use or claiming ah exemption. Appendix II to OMB Circular No. A- 130—Cost Accounting, Cost Recovery, and Interagency Sharing of Information Technology Facilities 1. Purpose. This Appendix establishes procedures for cost accounting, cost recovery, and interagency sharing of Federal information technology facilities. The Appendix revises procedures formerly contained in OMB Circular No. A-121, now rescinded. 2. Applicability. This Appendix applies to all information technology facilities that are operated by or on behalf of a Federal agency; provide information technology service to more than one user; operate one or more general management computers; and have obligations in excess of $3 million per year. 3. Definitions. a. The term “information technology facility” means an organizationally defined set of personnel, hardware, software, and physical facilities, a primary function of which is the operation of information technology. An information technology facility includes: (1) The personnel who operate computers or telecommunications systems; develop or maintain software; provide user liaison and training; schedule computers, prepare and control input data; control, reproduce, and distribute output data; maintain tape and disk libraries; provide security, maintenance, and custodial services; and directly manage or provide direct administrative support to personnel. engaged in these activities. (2) The owned or leased computer and telecommunications hardware, including central processing units; associated peripheral equipment such as disk drives, tape drives, drum storage, printers, card readers, and consoles; data entry equipment; data reproduction, decollation, booking, and binding equipment; telecommunications equipment including control units, terminals, modems, and dedicated telephone and satellite links provided by the facility to enable data transfer and access to users. Hardware acquired and maintained by users of the facility is excluded. (3) The software, including operating system software, utilities, sorts, language processors, access methods, data base processors, and other similar multi-user software required by the facility for support of the facility and/or for general use by users of the facility. All software acquired or maintained by users of the facility is excluded. {4} The physical facilities, including computer rooms; tape and disk libraries; stockrooms and warehouse space; office space; physical fixtures. b. The term “full costs” means all significant expenses incurred in the operation of an information technology facility. The following elements are included: (1) Personnel, including salaries, overtime, and fringe benefits of civilian and military personnel; training; and travel. (2) Equipment, including depreciation for owned, capitalized equipment; equipment rental or lease; and direct expenses for noncapitalized equipment (3) Software, including depreciation for capitalized costs of developing, converting, or acquiring software; rental of for software; and direct expenses for noncapitalized acquisition of software. (4) Supplies, including office supplies; data processing materials; and miscellaneous expenses. (5) Contracted services, including technical and consulting services; equipment maintenance; data entry support; operations support; facilities management; maintenance of software; and telecommunications network services. (8) Space occupancy, including rental and lease of buildings, general office furniture, and equipment; building maintenance; heating, air conditioning and other utilities; telephone services; power conditioning and distribution equipment and alternate power sources; and building security and custodial services. (7) Intra-agency services, including normal agency support services that are paid by die installation. (8) Interagency services, including services provided by other agencies and departments that are paid by the installation. c. The term “user” means ah organizational or programmatic entity that receives service from an information technology facility. A user may be either internal or external to the agency organization responsible for the facility, but normally does not report either to the manager or director of the facility or to the same immediate supervisor. d. The term “general management computer” means a digital computer that is used for any purpose other than as a part of a process control system, space system, mobile system, or a system meeting one of the exclusions identified in the Department of Defense Authorization Act of 1982. 4. Accounting and Reimbursement for Sharing o f Information Technology Facilities. a. Interagency Sharing. Agencies shall: (1) Share their information technology facilities with users from other agencies to the maximum extent feasible; (21 Document sharing arrangements, where the total annual reimbursement exceeds $500,000, with individual written agreements that identify: (a) Services available for sharing; (b) Service priority procedures and terms (e.g., quality performance standards) to be provided to each user; (c) Prices to be charged for providing services; (d) Reimbursement arrangements for services provided; and (e) Arrangements for terminating the sharing agreement; (3) Provide standard terms and conditions to users obtaining similar services insofar as possible; (4) Include such sharing arrangements, when fully documented and part of a formal sharing program, in justifications to OMB for resource requests (see OMB Circular No. A-ll, revised) and allocations. Direct funding by a shared facility should be requested only where exceptional circumstances preclude the user agency from using alternative sources. b. Cost Accounting. Agencies shall account for the full cost of the operation of information technology facilities. c. User Cost Distribution System. Agencies shall implement a system to distribute the full cost of providing services to all users. That system will: [PDF page 300; printed page 52742] 52742 Federal Register / Vol. 50, No. 247 / Tuesday, December 24, 1985 / Notices (1) Be consistent with guidance provided in the Federal Information Processing Standards Publication No. 96, “Guidelines for Developing and Implementing a Charging System for Data Processing Services” (National Bureau of Standards, Department of Commerce, 1982). (2) Price each service provided by the facility to the users of that service on an equitable basis commensurate with the amount of resources required to provide that service and the priority of service provided. The price of individual transactions may be estimated provided that they are periodically reconciled to assure that the full costs of operations are equitably distributed among all users. (3) Directly distribute to the recipient of the services the full costs of dedicated services, including applications developed and maintained; software unique to a single application; and telecommunications equipment, including control units, terminals, modems, and dedicated telephone or satellite links provided by the facility to enable data transfer and computer access to users. d. Cost Recovery. Consistent with statutory authority, agencies shall: (1) Submit periodic statements to all users of agency information technology facilities specifying the costs of services provided; (2) Recover full costs from Federal users of the facility; and (3) Recover costs from nonfederal users of the facilities consistent with OMB Circular No. A-25. e. Accounting for Reimbursements Received. Agencies shall: (1) Include resource requests for the amount of planned information technology use in user budget and appropriation requests; (2) Assure that shared facilities reduce budget and appropriation requests by the amount of planned reimbursements from users; (3) Prepare, at the close of each fiscal year, a report that documents in the agency's official records the full past year cost of operating information technology facilities that recover more than $500,000 per year from sharing reimbursements; and (4) Use the portion of reimbursements arising from equipment and software depreciation for the replacement of equipment and software capital assets, provided such usage is included in the agency’s budget, 5. Selection of Information Technology Facilities To Support New Applications. In selecting information technology facilities to support new applications, agencies shall establish a management control procedure for determining which facility will be used to support each significant application. This procedure shall ensure that: (a) All alternative facilities are considered, including other Federal agency and nonfederal facilities and services; (b) Agency rules do not require that priority be given to the use of in-house facilities; and (c) The user of the application has primary responsibility for selecting the facility. 6. Assignment of Responsibilities. a. All Federal Agencies. The head of each agency shall: (1) Establish policies and procedures and assign responsibilities to implement the requirements of this Appendix; and (2) Ensure that contracts awarded for the operation of information technology facilities include provisions for compliance with the requirements of this Appendix. b. General Services Administration. The Administration of General Services shall: (1) Ensure that information technology facilities designated as Federal Data Processing Centers comply with the procedures established by this Appendix; (2) Ensure that provisions consistent with this Appendix are included in contracts for the operation of information technology facilities when acquiring services on behalf of an agency: 7. Implementation Requirements. Agencies shall implement the provisions of this Appendix effective at the beginning of fiscal year 1987. Appendix III to OMB Circular No. A- 130—Security of Federal Automated Information Systems 1. Purpose. This Appendix establishes a minimum set of controls to be included in Federal automated information systems security programs; assigns responsibilities for the security of agency automated information systems; and clarifies the relationship between such agency security programs and internal control systems established in accordance with OMB Circular No. A-123, Internal Control Systems. The Appendix revises procedures formerly contained in Transmittal Memorandum No. 1 to OMB Circular No. A-71, now rescinded, and incorporates resjponsibilities from applicable national security directives. 2. Definitions. a. The term “automated information system” means an information system (defined in Section 6d of the Circular) that is automated. b. The term “information technology installation" means one or more computer or office automation systems including related telecommunications, peripheral and storage units, central processing units, and operating and support system software. Information technology installations may range from information technology facilities such as large centralized computer centers to individual stand-alone microprocessors such as personal computers. c. The term “sensitive data” means data that require protection due to the risk and magnitude of loss or harm that could result from inadvertent or deliberate disclosure, alteration, or destruction of the data. The term includes data whose improper use or disclosure could adversely affect the ability of an agency to accomplish its mission, proprietary data, records about individuals requiring protection under the Privacy Act, and data riot releasable under the Freedom of Information Act. d. The term “sensitive application’’ means an application of information technology that requires protection because it processes sensitive data, or because of the risk and magnitude of loss or harm that could result from improper operation or deliberate manipulation of the application. e. The term “security specifications” means a detailed description of the safeguards required to protect a sensitive application. - V . 3. Automated Information Systems Security Programs. Agencies shall assure an adequate level of security for all agency automated information systems, whether maintained in-house or commercially. Specifically, agencies shall: —Assure that automated information systems operate effectively and accurately; —Assure that there are appropriate technical, personnel, administrative, environmental, and telecommunications safeguards in automated information systems; and —Assure the continuity of operation of automated information systems that support critical agency functions. Agencies shall implement and maintain an automated information systems security prograrn, including the preparation of policies, standards, and procedures. This program will be consistent with government-wide policies, procedures, and standards issued by the Office of Management and Budget, the Department of Commerce, [PDF page 301; printed page 52743] Federal Register / Vol. 50, No. 247 / Tuesday, December 24, 1985 / Notices 52743 the Department of Defense, the General Services Administration, and the Office of Personnel Management. Agency programs shall incorporate additional requirements for securing national security information in accordance with appropriate national security directives. Agency programs shall, at a minimum, include four primary elements: applications security, personnel security, information technology installation security, and security awareness and training. a, Applications Security. (1) Management Control Process and Sensitivity Evaluation. Agencies shall establish a management control process to assure that appropriate administrative, physical, and technical safeguards are incorporated into all new applications, and into significant modifications to existing applications. Management officials who are the primary users of applications should evaluate the sensitivity of neto..or existing applications being substantially modified. For those applications considered sensitive, the management control process shall, at a minimum* include security specifications and design reviews and systems tests. (a) Security Specifications. Agencies shall define and approve security requirements and specifications prior'to acquiring or starting formal development of the applications. The results of risk analyses performed at the information technology installation where the applications will be processed should be taken into account whèn defining and approving security specifications for the applications. Other vulnerabilities of the applications, such as in telecommunications links, shall also be considered in defining security requirements. The views and recommendations of the information technology user organization, the information technology installation, and the individual responsible for security at the installation shall be considered prior ttf the approval of security specifications for the applications. (b) Design Reviews and System Tests. Agencies shall conduct and approve design reviews and system tests, prior to placing the application into operation, to assure the proposed design meets the approved security specifications. The objective of the system tests should be to verify that required administrative, technical, and physical safeguards are operationally adequate. The results of the design reviews and systems tests shall be fully documented and maintained in the official agency records. (c) Certification. Upon completion of the system tests, an agency official shall certify that the system meets all applicable Federal policies, regulations, and standards, and that the results of the tests demonstrate that the installed security safeguards are adequate for the application. (2) Periodic Review and Recertification-. Agencies shall conduct periodic audits or reviews of sensitive applications and recertify the adequacy of security safeguards. Audits or reviews shall evaluate the adequacy of implemented safeguards, assure they are functioning properly, identify vulnerabilities that could heighten threats to sensitive data or valuable resources, and assist with the implementation of new safeguards where required. They are intended to provide a basis for recertification of the ; security of the application. Recertification shall be fully - documented and maintained in the official agency records. Audits or reviews and recertifications shall be performed at least every three years. They should be considered as part of agency vulnerability assessments and internal control reviews conducted in accordance with OMB Circular No. A- 123. Security or other control weaknesses identified shall included in the annual internal control assura nce letter and report required by Circular No.A-123. (3) Contingency Plans. Agencies shall establish policies and assign ' responsibilities to assure that appropriate contingency plans are developed and maintained by end users of information technology applications. The intent of such plans is to assure that users can continue to perform essential functions in the event their information technology support is interrupted. Such plans should be consistent with disaster recovery and continuity of operations plans maintained by the installation at which the application is processed. b. Personnel Security. Agencies shall establish and manage personnel security policies and procedures to assure an adequatelevel of security for Federal automated information systems. Such policies and procedures shall include requirements for screening all individuals participating in the design, development, operation, or maintenance of sensitive applications as well as those having access to sensitive data. The level of screening required by these policies should vary from minimal checks to full background investigations, depending upon the sensitivity of the information to be handled and the risk and magnitude of loss or harm that could be caused by the individual. These policies shall be established for both Federal and contractor personnel. Personnel security policies for Federal employees shall be consistent with policies issued by the Office of Personnel Management. c. Information Technology Installation Security. Agencies shall assure that an appropriate level of security is maintained at all information technology installations operated by or on behalf of the Federal Government (e.g., government-owned, contractor- operated installations). (1) Assigning Responsibility. Agencies shall assign responsibility for the security of each installation to a management official knowledgeable in information technology and security matters. (2) Periodic Risk Analysis. Agencies shall establish and maintain a program for the conduct of periodic risk analyses at each installation to ensure that appropriate, cost effective safeguards are incorporated into existing and new installations. The objective of a risk analysis is to provide a measure of the relative vulnerabilities and threats to an installation so that security resources can be effectively distributed to minimize potential loss. Risk analyses may vary from an informal review of a microcomputer installation to a formal, fully quantified risk analysis of a large scale computer system. The results of these analyses should be documented and taken into consideration by management officials when certifying sensitive applications processed at the installation. Such analyses should also be consulted during the evaluation of general controls over the management of information technology installations conducted in accordance with OMB Circular No* A-123. A risk analysis shall be performed: (a) Prior to the approval of design specifications for installations; (b) Whenever a significant change occurs to the installations (e.g., adding a local area network; changing from batch to online processing; adding dial-up capability). Agency criteria for defining significant change shall be commensurate with the sensitivity of the data processed by the installation. (c) At periodic intervals established by the agency commensurate with the sensitivity of the data processed, but not to éxeeed every five years if no risk analysis have been performed during * that period. (3) Disaster and Continuity Plan. Agencies shall maintain disaster recovery and continuity of operations plans for all information technology installations. The objective of these plans should be to provide reasonable continuity of data processing support [PDF page 302; printed page 52744] 52744 Federai Register / should events occur that prevent normal operations at the installation. For large installations and installations that support essential agency functions, the plans should be fully documented and operationally tested periodically, at a frequency commensurate with the risk and magnitude of loss or harm that could result from disruption of information technology support. (4) Acquistion Specifications. Agencies shall assure that appropriate technical, administrative, physical, and personnel security requirements are included in specifications for the . acquisition or operation of information technology installations, equipment, software, and related services, whether procured by the agency or by GSA. These security requirements shall be reviewed and approved by the management official responsible for security at the installation making the acquisition. d. Security Awareness and Training Programs. Agencies shall establish a security awareness and training program to assure that agency and contractor personnel involved in the management, operation, programming, maintenance, or use of information technology are aware of their security responsibilities and know how to fulfill them. Users of information technology systems should be apprised of the vulnerabilities of such systems and trained in techniques to enhance security. 4. Assignment of Responsibilities. a . Department of Commerce. The Secretary of Commerce shall: (1) Develop and issue standards and guidelines for assuring the security of Federal automated information systems; (2) Establish standards, approved in accordance with applicable national security directives, for systems used to process sensitive information the loss of which could adversely affect the national security interest; and (3) Provide technical assistance to Federal agencies in implementing Department of Commerce standards and guidelines. b. Department of Defense. The Secretary of Defense shall: (1) Act, in accordance with applicable national security directives, as executive agent of the government for the security of telecommunications and automated information systems that process information the loss of which could adversely affect the national security interest; and (2) Provide technical material and assistance o.t Federal agencies concerning security o,f Federal telecommunications and automated information systems. Voi. 50, No. 247 / Tuesday, December c. General Services Administration. The Administrator of General Services shall: (1) Issufe policies and regulations for the physical and environmental security of computer rooms in Federal buildings consistent with standards issued by the Department of Commerce and the Department of Defense. (2) Assure, that agency procurement requests for computers, software, telecommunications services, and related services include security requirements. Delegations of procurement authority to agencies by GSA under mandatory programs, dollar threshold delegations, certification programs, or other so-called blanket delegations shall include requirements for agency specification of security requirements. (3) Assure that information technology equipment, software, computer room construction, guard or custodial services, telecommunications services, and any other related services procured by GSA meet the security requirements, established and specified by the user agency and are consistent with other applicable policies and standards issued by OMB, the Department of Commerce, the Department of Defense, and the Office of Personnel Management. (4) Issue appropriate standards for the security of Federal telecommunications systems. Standards related to systems used to communicate sensitive information, the loss of which could adversely affect the national security interest, shall be developed and issued in accordance with applicable national security directives. d. Off ice of Personnel Management. The Director, Office of Personnel Management, shall maintain personnel security policies for Federal personnel associated with the design, programming, operation, maintenance, or use of Federal automated information systems. Requirements for personnel checks imposed by these policies should vary commensurate with the risk and magnitude of loss or harm that could be caused by the individual. The checks may range from merely normal reemployment screening procedures to full background investigations. 5. Reports. In their annual internal control report to the President and the Congress, required under OMB Circular No. A-123, agencies shall: a. Describe any security or other control weaknesses identifed during aduits or reviews of sensitive applications or when conducting risk analyses of installations; and b. Provide assurance that there is adequate security of agency automated information systems. 24, 1985 / Notices Appendix IV to OMB Circular No. A- 130—Analysis of Key Sections 1. Purpose The purpose of this Appendix is to provide a general context and explanation for the contests of the key sections of the Circular, 2. Background The Paperwork Reduction Act of 1980, Pub. L. 90-511, 94 Stat 2812, codified at Chapter 35 of Title 44 of the United States Code, establishes a broad mandate for agencies to perform their information activities in an efficient, effective, and economical manner. Section 3504 of the Act provides authority to the Director, Office of Management and Budget [OMB), to develop and implement uniform and consistent information resources management policies; oversee the development and promote the use of information management principles, standards, and guidelines; evaluate agency information management practices in order to determine their adequacy and efficiency; and determine compliance of such practices with the policies, principles, standards, and guidelines promulgated by the Director. The Circular implements OMB authority under the Act with respect to Section 3504(b), general information policy, Section 3504(e), records management, Section 3504(f), privacy, and Section 3504{g), Federal automatic data processing and telecommunications; the Privacy Act of 1974 (5 U.S.C. 552a); Sections 111 and 206 of the Federal Property and Administrative Services Act of 1949, as amended (40 U.S.C. 759 and 487, respectively); the Budget and Accounting Act of 1921 (31 U.S.C. 1 et seq.); and Executive Order No. 12046 of March 27,1978 and Executive Order No. 12472 of April 3,1984, Assignment of National Security and Emergency Telecommunications Functions. The Circular complements 5 CFR Part 1320, Controlling Paperwork Burden on the Public, which implements other sections of the Paperwork Reduction Act dealing with controlling the reporting and recordkeeping burden placed on the public. In addition, the Circular revises and consolidated policy and procedures in five existing OMB directives and rescinds those directives, as follows: A-71—Responsibilities for the Administration and Management of Automatic Data Processing Activities Transmittal Memorandum No. 1 to Circular No. À-71—Security of [PDF page 303; printed page 52745] 52745Federal Register / Federal Automated Information Systems A-90—Cooperating with State and Local Governments to Coordinate and Improve Information Systems A-108—Responsibilities for the Maintenance of Records about Individuals by Federal Agencies A-121—Cost Accounting, Cost Recovery, and Interagency Sharing of Data Processing Facilities. OMB’s review of the five existing policy directives led to the conclusion that much, but not all, of their content was procedural in nature, concerned chiefly with how policies were to be carried out OMB determined that it was important clearly to distinguish the statement of policies from the procedures for implementing those policies. For this reason, the main body of the Circular consists of basic considerations and assumptions, policies, and assignments of responsibility; the appendices to the Circular consist of procedures for implementing various policies and with analysis of key sections. OMB developed the main body of the Circular relying upon comments on the Federal Register notice as well as other forms of Federal agency and public input, principally meetings with interested parties. For the procedural revisions, OMB relied on the assistance of interagency task groups. The revised contents of OMB Circular No. A-71, dealing with assignments of responsibilities, are in the main body of this Circular. The contents of OMB Circular No. A-90 are rescinded entirely, with the exception of a policy statement at Section 8(b)(17) of this Circular. Revisions of the procedural aspects of the other three policy directives— Transmittal Memorandum No. 1 to A-71, A-108, and A-121—are appendices to this Circular. Appendices I, II, and III have the same prescriptive force as the Circular; Appendix IV is an explanatory document. On September 17,1984, the President signed National Security Decision Directive (NSDD) No. 145, National Policy on Telecommunications and Automated Information Systems Security. The NSDD requires that the Director, OMB, review for consistency with NSDD, and amend as appropriate, OMB Circular No. A-71, Transmittal Memorandum No. 1. The Circular and Appendix III satisfy the NSDD requirement. 3. Analysis Section 6. Definitions. f. Access to information, g. Dissemination of information. The Vol. 50, No. 247 / Tuesday, December Circular defines “access to information” as the function of providing to members of the public, upon their request, the government information to which they are entitled under law. Access refers to those situations in which the government agency’s role is passive; access is what the government’s responsibilities are when the public comes to the government and ask for information the government has and the public is entitled to. “Dissemination,” in the Circular’s usage, refers to the function of distributing government information; dissemination connotes an active outreach by a government agency. Dissemination refers to those situations in which the government provides the public with information without the public having to come and ask for it. The distinction between access and dissemination is posed in order to elaborate the responsibilities of Federàl agencies for providing information to the public. Two fundamentally different situations exist: one in which the public goes to the agency to ask for information the agency holds and may or may not have disseminated; and one in which the agency chooses to take the information it holds to the public. In the first instance—access—Congress has provided specific statutory policy in the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) and in the Privacy Act These laws and policies concerning access to government information are explicit, well known, and now so widely accepted in practice by Federal agencies as not to require policy elaboration in this Circular. Agencies should know that, if members of the public ask for information subject to TOI A or the Privacy Act, the agencies should normally provide the information forthwith, because the public has a formal legal process for forcing the agencies to yield the information. Thiatelatiqnship between access to the dissemination of information is explained below, in the discussion of 8a (8) through (12). Section 7. Basic Considerations and Assumptions Basic considerations and assumptions are statements that provide the underpinnings for the prescriptive policies in Section 8; they are not themselves policy statements. They are either derived from statutes or legislative history, or represent executive branch management philosophy as embodied in the Circular. —Statements 7-a through 7-d provide the general context for management of Federal information resources. 24, 1985 / Notices —Statement 7-e summarizes policy found in OMB Circular No. A-76, Performance of Commercial Activities. —Statement 7-f states a general predisposition to use up-to-dàtd information technology to manage Federal information resources. —Statements 7-g and 7-h pertain to the Privacy Act and the Freedom of Information Act, respectively. —Statement 7-i pertains to the National Science and Technology Policy, Organization and Priorities Act. —Statement 7-j pertains to the Federal Records Act. —Statement 7-k states a relationship between Federal information policy and international information policy. Section 8. Policies This section is divided into two subsections that generally correspond to the twofold definition of information resources management in Section 6-b, namely, information itself and the resources associated with information. a. Information Management. The Paperwork Reduction Act acknowledges that information is a valuable resource and should be managed as such. Proceeding from this premise, this subsection states policies concerning the management of Federal information. (1) and (2). Information Collection and Sharing. The Circular’s basic considerations and assumptions (Section 7) establish the value of government information activities. Without question, some information created or collected by Federal agencies is so vital that the American form of government, the economy, national security, and citizens’ safety and wellbeing could not continue to exist in its absence. Nothing in this Circular is intended to diminish or derogate the creation or collection of such information, nor to serve as a pretext under which a Federal agency could damage the Nation’s critical needs by failing to create or collect such information. At the same time, the Paperwork Reduction Act was designed to remedy deficiencies Congress perceived in Federal information activities. In the words of the report of the House Committee on Government Operations (Report No. 96-835, p. 3): The legislation is the result of a growing concern that the way the Government * collects, uses, and disseminates information must be improved. Inefficiencies in current Federal information practices drastically reduce the effectiveness of the Government while, at the same time, drowning our [PDF page 304; printed page 52746] 52746 Federal Register / Vol. 50, No. 247 / Tuesday, December 24, 1985 / Notices citizens in a sea of forms, questionnaires, and reports. The Act intends that the creation or collection of information be carried out within the context of efficient, effective, and economical management. When Federal agencies create or collect information—just as when they perform any other vital functions—they consume scarce resources and such activities must be continually scrutinized in light of good management principles. The applicable principles provided in the purposes of the Act are: —To minimize the Federal paperwork burden for individuals, small businesses, State and local governments, and other persons; —To minimize the cost to the Federal Government of collecting, maintaining, using and disseminating information; and —To maximize the usefulness of information collected by the Federal Government. (44 U.S.C. 3501} Agencies must justify the creation or collection of information in the light of their statutory functions. Policy statement 8a(9) uses the standard, “necessary for the proper performance of agency functions,” taken directly from the Paperwork Reduction Act (44 U.S.C. 3504(c)(2)). Further, the policy statement includes the requirement that the information have practical utility, as defined in the Paperwork Reduction Act (44 U.S.C. 3502(15)) and elaborated in Controlling Paperwork Burdens on the Public (5 CFR Part 1320). Note that practical utility includes characteristics pertaining to the quality of information such as accuracy, adequacy, and reliability, and that, in the case of general purpose statistics or recordkeeping, practical utility means that actual uses can be demonstrated (5 CFR 1320.7 (q)). Good management and the requirement of practical utility dictate that agencies must plan from the outset for the steps in the information life cycle. The Act also stipulates that agencies must “formulate plans for tabulating the information in a manner which will enhance its usefulness to other agencies and to the public” (44 U.S.C. 3507(a)(1)(C)). When creating or collecting information, agencies must plan how they will process and transmit the information, how they will use it, what provisions they will make for access to it, whether and how they will disseminate it, how they will store it, and'finally, how the information will ultimately be disposed of. While agencies cannot at the outset achieve absolute certitude in planning for each of these processes, the requirement for information resources planning is clearly contained in the Act (44 U.S.C. 3506(c)(1)), and the absence of adequate planning is sufficient reason not to create or collect information in the first place. Before creating or collecting new information, agencies should look first to other agencies and the private sector so as not to duplicate existing information sources or services that would satisfy their needs. The Act requires that agencies shall not conduct or sponsor information collections unless they have eliminated collections “which seek to obtain information available from another source within the Federal Government” (44 U.S.C. 3507(a)(1)(A)). Each agency must also “ensure its information systems do not overlap each other or duplicate the systems of other agencies” (44 U.S.C. 3506(c)(2)). The Act also contains provisions governing the sharing of information between agencies (44 U.S.C. 3510). Applying the policy of OMB Circular No. A-76, the Circular also requires agencies to examine the possibility of acquiring the necessary information from private sector sources. This is not to say that information creation or collection functions should be indiscriminately turned over to other agencies or to the private sector, but rather to say that agencies have an obligation to examine other potential sources of information which may satisfy agency needs. Some information can only be created or collected by Federal agencies themselves in the exercise of the government’s sovereign powers. For some information, the government can satisfy its legitimate needs only when a Federal agency is the creation or collection agent But other information needs can be met, and in many cases are routinely met, through existing services and sources in other agencies or the private sector. In many cases there is no inherently governmental function that is served by having information collected by a Federal agency; agencies should and do consider acquiring information collection services from the private sector. The Circular emphasizes that these sources should always be looked to first in the interests of efficiency and economy. (3) through (6). Privacy Act and Freedom of Information Act. These statements contain policy statements pertaining to the Privacy Act and incorporating the policies of OMB Circular No. A-108, which is rescinded and superseded. Agencies are to ensure that they meet the requirements of the Privacy Act regarding collection of individually identifiable information. Such information is to be maintained and protected so as to preclude intrusion into the privacy of individuals. Individuals must be accorded access and amendment rights to records, as provided in the Privacy Act. Appendix I prescribes procedures for the maintenance of records about individuals in accordance with the Privacy Act. In addition to Privacy Act considerations, statements (3) and (4) include provisions concerning proprietary information. Agencies are to minimize their collection of proprietary information, consistent with legal requirements and operational necessity and, when such information must be collected, agencies must provide for its protection. (7) . Training. Agency personnel must receive proper training to safeguard information resources. Training is particularly important in view of the changing nature of information resources management. The development of end user computing and office automation, for example, place the management of information and information technology in the hands of nearly all agency personnel rather than in the hands of a few employees at centralized facilities such as large computer centers. Policies and procedures for computer security, records management, protection of privacy, and other safeguards need to be incorporated into information resources management training programs. (8) through (12). Information Dissemination. (8) and (9). General Policy. How does the public know what information is available from Federal agencies? That is, given the distinction the Circular makes between access and dissemination, what is the relationship between the two? How does the public know what government information is accessible? The answer is: through the government’s dissemination of information on what is available and how to gain to access it. The Freedom of Information Act requires each agency to publish currently in the Federal Register, for the guidance of the public, descriptions of agency organization; where and how the public may obtain information; the general course and methods by which agency functions are determined, including all procedural requirements; rules of procedure; descriptions of forms and how to obtain them; substantive regulations; statements of general policy; and revisions to all the foregoing (5 U.S.C. 552(a)(1)). The Privacy Act also requires publication of information [PDF page 305; printed page 52747] Federal Register / Vol. 50, No. 247 / Tuesday, December 24, 1985 / Notices 52747 concerning systems of records (see Appendix I); the Government in the Sunshine Act requires agencies to make public announcement of meetings (5 U.S.C. 552b(e)(l)). The Paperwork Reduction Act (44 U.S.C. 3507(a)(2)) and Controlling Paperwork Burdens on the Public (5 CFR Part 1320) require agencies to publish notices when they submit information collection requests for OMB approval. In sum, every Federal agency has obligations to disseminate basic information to the public concerning what the agency does, how its programs operate, what the public must do to comply with laws or regulations, how to receive benefits, and how the public can use agency services. These obligations are the basic linkage between access to, and dissemination of, government information. Beyond generic requirements, specific laws affect agency dissemination of information in two ways. First, for some agencies their basic enabling legislation stipulates that information dissemination impart of their statutory mission. General purpose statistical agencies, for example, have information dissemination as part of their very reason for existence. These agencies conduct substantial information dissemination programs in order to carry out their necessary functions. In contrast, other agencies such as some regulatory agencies have basic information access, but minimal information dissemination, responsibilities; the existence of substantial information dissemination programs in such agencies would be unusual. Second, statutes may sometimes require that agencies produce and disseminate specific information products or services. For example, the law may state that the President or head of an agency shall make reports to the Congress, on given subjects; these would be legally required disseminations of information. Beyond generic and specific statutory requirements, agencies have positive' obligations to disseminate information as a necessary part of performing their functions. Each agency head must clarify the nature of these obligations for the agency’s particular mission and set appropriate boundaries for dissemination functions. Before deciding to disseminate an information product or service, and periodically therefore, an agency must be able to demonstrate that the dissemination of the product or service passes the test of either being required by law or being necessary for the proper performance of agency functions. In conformity with the purposes of the Paperwork Reduction Act, the agency’s positive obligations to disseminate information must be discharged within a responsible management framework of minimizing costs to the Federal Government while maximizing the usefulness of the information. Efficient, effective, and economical dissemination does not translate into diminishing or limiting the flow of information from the agency to the public. To the contrary, good management of information resources should result in more useful information flowing with greater facility to the public, at less cost to the taxpayer. Given an adequate basis for dissemination, agencies must also ask themselves whether a proposed or existing information product or service substantially duplicates similar products or services that would otherwise be available, either from another agency or from the private sector. This requirement of non-duplication, originating in the Paperwork Reduction Act, husbands scarce resources and leads to more efficient, effective, and economical information dissemination by the government. Similarly, the fact that an agency has created or collected information is not itself a valid reason for creating a program, products, or service to disseminate the information to the public. Agencies create and collect much information, often for purely internal governmental purposes, that is not intended for dissemination, for which there is no public demand, and the dissemination of which would serve no public purpose and would not be cost-justified; e.g., compilations of routine time and attendance records for Federal employees, or publication of the thousands of pages of common carrier tariff filings by regulatory agencies. While such information may be subject to access upon request under provisions of agency statutes, the Freedom of Information Act, or the Privacy Act, the agency must demonstrate in each case the need actively to disseminate such information. Over time, changes in laws, economic conditions, or information — technology can result in changes in public demand, public purpose, or dissemination costs; for example, an agency’s shift to electronic filing of reports, perhaps carried out primarily in order to improve internal information management, might generate a public demand for electronic dissemination that could be satisfied at minimal cost to the government and also improve the performance of the agency’s information access function. The decision to disseminate information, however, entails potentially significant costs, must be addressed separately from the decision to create or collect information, and must hinge, upon a determination that dissemination is necessary for proper performance of agency functions. If agencies do contemplate disseminating particular information, they should plan for its dissemination when creating or collecting the information (see 8a(l)). Planning for dissemination should proceed from the Paperwork Reduction Act premises of minimizing the cost to the government while maximizing the usefulness of information. The focus of information dissemination plans should be on elevating to a policy level decisions regarding the agency’s positive obligations to disseminate information and ensuring that the agency discharges the obligations in the most efficient, effective, and economical manner. (10) Adequate Notice. Because many government information activities are important to the government and to the public, agencies must exercise care not to act capriciously with respect to information products and services. When agencies intend to commence offering new products or services, they should provide adequate advance notice so that the public may comment as to the need for the product or service. For example, if private sector interests believe they are already offering or are about to offer the same or a similar product or service—in which event the government may potentially be entering into unfair competition—such notjce will allow these interests to present their case before the product or service is launched. By the same token, if many members of the public greatly depend on a particular product or service, they should be permitted to voice their views to an agency that is contemplating termination of the product or service. The Circular refers to "significant” information products and services. It is not the Circular’s intent that agencies should follow notice and comment procedures when terminating relatively inconsequential information products and services; examples might be minor brochures or flyers, products and >r services that were never intended to be continuing, or for which there is now little or no public audience. Agencies should determine for themselves . whether information products and services are “significant,” and in some cases may wish to establish procedures and thershold criteria for making such determinations. If a product or service is considered significant, as determined ultimately by the agency head, the [PDF page 306; printed page 52748] 52748 Federal Register / Vol. 50, No. 247 / Tuesday, December 24, 1985 / Notices agency may be well advised to follow notice and comment procedures prior to initiation or termination. (ll)(a). Reaching the Public; Avoiding Information Monopolies. When agencies have justified and made the basic decision to disseminate information, they must also satisfy conditions regarding the manner of dissemination. First, agencies must take steps to ensure that members of the public who the/ agency has an obligation to reach have a resonable ability to acquire the information. The audiences for information products and services will vary, and agencies should tailor the dissemination methods so as to place the information into the hands of those whom the agency intends to receive it. Federal agencies are often the sole holders of certain information; hence, when they disseminate, they are sole suppliers and in a position of natural monopoly. When agencies use private sector,contractors to accomplish dissemination, they must take care that they do not permit contractors to exercise monopolistic controls in ways that defeat the agencies’ information dissemination obligations, for example, by setting unreasonably high prices. In some cases agencies may need to formulate contractual terms with a sole supplier contractor so that the contractor functions as a mere intermediary for the agency in dealing with end users in the public. (ll)(b). Reliance on the Private Sector. In disseminating information—as with other activities—agencies must act in the most cost effective manner, which includes maximum feasible reliance on the private sector. This is merely an application to agency information dissemination programs of the policy stated in OMB Circular No. A-76, Performance of Commercial Activities, and summarized in Section 7f of this Circular. It is “the general policy of the government to rely on commercial sources to supply the products and services the government needs,” including products and services the government needs in order to disseminate information to the public. For example, before an agency establishes a service for electronic dissemination of government information via an online computer system, the agency should compare the cost of contracting for operation of the service versus in-house performance and determine whether in-house performance is less costly both for the government and for the public who will receive the service. Policies contained in OMB Circular No. A-76 are applicable to information dissemination, including the policy that inherently governmental functions should be performed by government employees. The general policy of reliance on the private sector is balanced by the “inherent governmental function” policy, and the Circular in no way intends to abrogate the latter. Where agencies determine that information dissemination activities are inherently governmental, the agencies themselves should carry out the activities. (11) (c). User Charges. The Federal Government is the sole possessor and supplier of certain types of information, which is frequently of substantial commerical value. Dissemination of such information, or its dissemiqation in a specific form or medium, may represent a government service from which identifiable recipients derive special benefits, in which case they may be subject to OMB Circular No. A-25, User Charges. For example, where the information is already substantially available in printed form, agencies may consider dissemination in electronic form to be a service of special benefit, the costs of which should be recovered through user charges. Many agencies do not have consistent, agency-wide policies and procedures for setting user charges for information products arid services with a view to cost recovery. Agencies must establish user charges for the costs of information dissemination, and recover such costs, where appropriate. Whether user charges are appropriate depends, in principle, on whether identifiable recipients will receive special benefits from information products and services. The requirement to establish user charges is not, however, intended to make the ability to pay the sole criterion for determining whether the public receives government information. Agencies must balance the requirement to establish user charges and the level of fees charged against other policies, specifically, the proper performance of agency functions and the need to ensure that information products and services reach the public for whom they are intended (see Section 8a(ll)(a)). If an agency has a positive obligation to place a given product or service in the hands of certain specific groups or members of the public and also determines that user charges will constitute a significant barrier to discharging this obligation, the agency may have grounds for reducing or eliminating its user charges for the product or service, or for exempting some recipients from the charge. (12) . Periodic Review and Depository Libraries. Agencies must also establish procedures for periodically reviewing their information dissemination programs. Agency information dissemination plans must ask whether the agency should disseminate a given information product or service at all; if the agency is already disseminating the product or service, reviews should ask whether the agency should continue to do so; or whether the manner or medium of dissemination is the most efficient, effective, and economical.: In addition, agencies must establish procedures to ensure compliance with 44 U.S.C. 1902, which requires that government publications (defined in 44 U.S.G. 1901 and repeated in Section 6k of the Circular) be made available to the Federal depository libraries through the Government Printing Office. The depository libraries provide a kind of information “safety net” to the public, an existing institutional mechanism that guarantees a minimum level of availability of government information to all members of the public. Providing publications to the depository library program complies with the law and costs executive agencies virtually nothing. b. Information Systems and Information Technology Management. This subsection states policies concerning the planning, acquisition, operation, and management of Federal information systems and technology. The Federal information systems and technology budget, which was $14 billion in FY1985, is projected to increase at a rate faster than that of the overall Federal budget. With outlays at these levels and agencies becoming increasingly dependent upon information technology to accomplish their missions, it is essential that planning processes be applied to the acquisition and application of information technology. (1). Planning. The Paperwork Reduction Act mandates a stronger central role in information resources planning. Specifically, the Act requires that OMB: (1) publish a five-year government-wide automatic data processing and telecommunications plan; (2) review and coordinate agency proposals for the acquisition and use of information technology; and (3) promote the use of the technology to improve governmental efficiency arid effectiveness. In order to meet these objectives, it is necessary to initiate a government-wide process for developing and institutionalizing information technology planning that is based in agency programs and missions. The planning must also be tied to the budget so that budgetary decisions derive from plans, and conversely, so that budgetary constraints are reflected in the plans. [PDF page 307; printed page 52749] Federal Register / Vol. 50, No. 247 f Tuesday, December a 'j f w r n ™ ■«!! 'l iim ij w m Ê a B m B B M m Ê m Ê a ssz m m K Ê Ê Ê K K cm m æ K m m Ê Ê Ê B & m Ê Ê Ê S M tm m Ê m tB Ê im G m a ia Ê Ê Ê Ê m Ê Ê K Ê Ê Ê Ê a m Ê m m m im Ê U H Ê S Ê M m K m m Ê B The process must further ensure that sufficient information is available to the central agencies to enable them to monitor compliance with Federal policies and identify major issues, including cross-cutting issues where more active centralized planning and management may be appropriate. Hence, agencies must institute information planning processes tied to both the conduct of programs and the preparation of the agency’s budget. (2) and (3). Management Controls and Accountability. Basic management controls for agency information systems are fundamental to sound information resources management. These controls should ensure the documentation and periodic review of major information systems, as well as periodic cost-benefit evaluation of overall information resources management in light of agency missions. In order to provide greater incentative for management efficiencies, accountability for information systems should be vested in the officials responsible for operating the programs that the systems support. Program managers depend upon information systems to carry out their programs, and yet frequently they do not have direct control over the technical and operational support for those systems. Program managers often depend upon agency computer centers or contracted service organizations, the heads of which may not be directly accountable to the program managers in a formal organizational sense. Program managers are nonetheless responsible for conducting their programs and, to the extent successful conduct of the programs entails support from information systems, program managers must be held accountable for acquiring that support. The responsibilities of program managers are therefore presumed to include securing information systems support as needed, and planning for contingencies. Technical support organizations have a concomitant responsibility to meet their commitments, contractual or otherwise, to their program clients, but the program official has the ultimate responsibility for delivering a program’s product or service. * • (4) and (5). Sharing Information Processing Capacity. OMB Circular No. A-l 21, which is rescinded and superseded; required only that the holder of excess automatic data processing capacity share such capacity. Because thé holder of excess capacity has little incentive to seek opportunities for sharing, however, the new policy requires both that the holder share capacity and that the agency seeking information processing capacity fulfill its needs from other agencies or the private sector, whenever possible, before acquiring the new capacity itself. The policy establishes an order of preference in meeting needs—look first to existing sources before acquiring new capacity-^-butis not intended to assert blindly that sharing or commercial sources are the sole considerations. Agencies must elso consider whether existing sources are more cost effective and whether they in fact will meet agency specific needs. Procedural aspects of these policy statements are found in Appendix II. (6) and (7). Life Cycle Costing; and A voiding Duplication. Agencies frequently develop information technology incrementally, through a series of interim upgrades, without regard for longer term considerations such as the information systems’life cycle. As part of their planning, agencies need to consider the full information system life cycle when determining the cost of information technology. While competitive procurement is generally to be valued, its costs should be taken into account, including the cost to program effectiveness of unnecessarily lengthy procurement processes. Other conditions, such as the need for compatibility, may also be legitimate limitations on the competitive process. Similarly, agency planning should ensure that information systems are not unnecessarily duplicative of systems available elsewhere in government or from the private sector, (8) . Software Management. The prevailing agency practice of developing customized computer software is a source of inefficiency, as the General Accounting Office and others have noted. While some agency applications can only be satisfied with customized software, the tendency to prefer custom development is excessively costly in terms of initial development, continued maintenance, and eventual conversion to new technology, because it requires the agency to bear the full cost of developing and maintaining the software it uses. While recognizing that off-the-shelf software has pitfalls, such as uncertainty of continued maintenance, managers are generally to prefer acquiring generic, off-the-shelf software available from the private sector instead of developing their own. (9) . Necessary Compatibility. Agencies often acquire technology that is incapable of communicating with other systems with which the agencies need to communicate. Compatibility among information systems has consequently emerged as a significant 24, 1985 / Notices 52749 mxmmrmmwmmmÊÊÊÊmBmimmmmÊÊÊÊmÊÊBtÊÊiÊmÊÊÊÊmmmmmmmmm ii 'i i n r — information resources management problem. Agencies must acquire or develop information systems in a manner that enhances necessary compatibility. The qualifier “necessary” is used because compatibility is not an unrestricted goal; information systems nëed to be compatible with other systems only to the extent that they must communicate with those systems. (10) through (13). Security. Security of information systems means both the protection of information while it is within the systems and also the assurance that the systems do exactly what they are supposed to do and nothing more. Information system security entails management controls to ensure the integrity of operations including such matters as proper access to the information in the systems and proper handling of input and output. In this sense, security of information systems is first and foremost a management issue and only secondly a technical problem of computer security. The recent introduction of smaller and more powerful computer systems and new communications technology and transmission media, together with the greater involvement of end users in managing information resources, have increased the potential vulnerability of Federal information systems and hence the level of management concern. Protecting personal, proprietary, and other sensitive data from unauthorized access or misuse; detecting and preventing computer related fraud and abuse; and assuring continuity of operations of major information systems in the event of emergency related disruptions are increasingly serious policy issues. Policy previously found in Transmittal Memorandum No. 1 to OMB Circular No. A-71 is here revised; procedural aspects of the policy are in Appendix III to the Circular. The General Accounting Office reported in its review of the first-year implementation of the Federal Managers Financial Integrity Act (FIA) that internal controls in automatic data processing systems received inadequate coverage in FIA evaluations. GAO noted that some agencies were uncertain of the relationship between (a) OMB Circular No. A-71, Transmittal Memorandum No. 1, Security of Federal Automated Information Systems, and (b) OMB Circular No. A-123, Internal Control Systems. The relationship between security of automated information systems and agency internal control reports is now stated clearly in Appendix III. Appendix III provides a minimal set of requirements for the security of all [PDF page 308; printed page 52750] 52750 Federal Register / Voi. 50, No. 247 / Tuesday, December 24, 1985 / Notices Federal automated information systems. The Appendix also requires agencies to incorporate additional requirements for the security of information classified for national security purposes, in accordance with appropriate national security directives. (14) Standards. The National Bureau of Standards, Department of Commerce, develops and issues Federal Information Processing Standards. The National Communications System develops and the General Services Administration issues Federal Telecommunications Standards. Some standards are mandatory for Federal agencies, while others are voluntary. Agencies may waive the use of Federal standards under certain conditions and pursuant to certain procedures, which vary depending upon the individual standard. In general, OMB strongly recommends use of these standards government- wide. Such standards can contribute to overall government economy and efficiency by increasing compatibility in computer and telecommunications networks, improving the transportability of software, and enabling computer systems to be developed using components of different manufacturers. These advantages can result in reducèd procurement costs for equipment and services, improved competition, and better utilization of staff training and skills. While govern ment-wide standards can result in management efficiencies, agencies should be mindful that standards can also have the untoward effects of regulations, as noted in OMB Circular No. A-119. Agencies should continuously assess relative costs and benefits of standards and their effects upon the agency’s accomplishment of its mission. Note also that national security directives prescribe standards for computer security. (15) A voiding Information Technology Monopolies. Many agencies operate one or more central information technology facilities to support agency programs. In these agencies, program managers are often required to use the central facilities. The manager of such a monopoly facility has a lesser incentive to control costs, since he or she has a captive clientele. The program manager has little leverage to ensure that information processing resources are efficiently allocated since he'or she cannot seek, or can seek only with great difficulty, alternative sources of supply. When users are dependent on effective technology support to perform their functions, control over selection of facility is essential and consistent with holding users responsible for producing their government information products. To provide incentives conducive to more businesslike procedures in information technology facilities, agencies should avoid monopolistic information processing arrangements and should enter into them only if their cost effectiveness is clear and they are subject to periodic review. Appendix II specifies certain procedures with respect to this policy. (16) Cost Recovery. This policy constitutes a revision to policy stated in OMB Circular No. A-121. Whereas Circular Nb. A-121 required only that costs for automatic data processing facilities be' allocated to users, agencies must now recover the costs of information technology facilities from government users. Viable management of a large information technology facility requires that managers know the amount of resources devoted to each user when providing services. Furthermore, effective management of the use of information technology requires that the user have responsibility for and control over the resources consumed by use of the facility. Experience with Circular No. A- 121 showed OMB that allocating costs had little effect on agencies’ behavior; recovering costs means that actual transfers of funds will take place between suppliers and users of information technology facilities! Procedural aspects of the policy appear in Appendix II. (17) Coordination with State and Local Governments. This policy reaffirms policy previously found in OMB Circular No. A-90, Transmittal Memorandum No. 1. The interagency group that worked on the revision of Circular No. A-90 recommended, and OMB agreed, that the Circular should be rescinded except for a single policy statement prohibiting Federal agencies from placing unnecessary restrictions on the information systems that State and local governments use to carry out federally financed program activities. ; (18) Application of Up-to-date Information Technology. Recent availability of low cost, highly efficient and effective electronic information technology can greatly increase worker productivity and facilitate operation of Federal agency programs. The Circular states a predisposition, based in the Paperwork Reduction Act, in favor of applying such technology to the information life cycle within a responsible management context. Two broad areas of information technology merit further discussion: (1) electronic information collection and dissemination, and {2} end user computing. —Electronic Collection and Dissemination of Information. Federal agencies are moving rapidly to provide for collection and dissemination of information through electronic media. In developing this Circular, OMB considered whether it was necessary to provide specific policies concerning electronic Collection and dissemination of governmental information. OMB concluded that, except for the general predisposition in favor of applying new technological developments to information resources management, the policies that apply to information Collection and dissemination in other media also apply to electronic collection and dissemination. It is important, however, that agencies V recognize the necessity of systematically thinking through the application of policies stated elsewhere in this Circular to electronic collection and dissemination of information. For example, when developing electronic collection programs, agencies should give particular attention to issues such as privacy, public access, and records management. When developing electronic dissemination programs, agencies should ensure that access is provided to each class of users upon reasonable terms, avoid problems ¿rising from monopolistic control, ensure maximum reliance upon the private sector, and take necessary steps for cost accounting and cost recovery. —End User Computing. Federal agencies are also moving rapidly to acquire end user computing capabilities. OMB endorses the ; managed innovation approach to end user computing presented in GSA’s publication Managing End User Computing in the Federal Government (June 1983). Because end user computing places management of information in the hands of individual agency personnel rather than in a centrai automatic data processing organization, the Circular requires that agencies train end users in their responsibilities for safeguarding information; Appendix III deals in part with the security of end user computing. Section 9. Assignment of Responsibilities This section assigns responsibilities for the management of Federal information resources addressed in this Circular. OMB Circular No. A-71 is [PDF page 309; printed page 52751] Federal Register / Vol. 50, No. 247 / Tuesday, December 24, 1985 / Notices 52751 rescinded and its contents are revised and incorporated into this section along with responsibilities assigned under the Paperwork Reduction Act; Section 111 of the Federal Property and Administrative Services Act, as amended; and Executive Order No. 12046. Certain assignments of responsibility from OMB to other agencies, as noted below, are also included. Following are principal noteworthy aspects of this section. Responsibility for Managing Information Resources. Statement 9a(l) is a key element in the Circular because it establishes that the locus of responsibility for actual management of Federal information resources is the head of each agency. This means, for example, that the determination of what is “necessary for the proper performance of agency functions’’ with respect to information creation or collection (8a(l)) and information dissemination (8a(9)) lies with the head of the agency. In the Circular OMB sets the policy framework within which such determinations are to be made and the standards and provisions for reviewing the determinations, but the management decisions and their implementation belong properly with the agency holding the information resources. Triennial Reviews. The Paperwork Reduction Act provides that the Director of OMB “. . . shall, with the advice and assistance of the Administrator of General Services, selectively review, at least once every three years, the information management activities of each agency to ascertain their adequacy and efficiency.” (44 U,S.C. 3513) The Administrator of Information and Regulatory Affairs, OMB, and the Deputy Administrator of the General Services Administration, in an exchange of correspondence dated June 13 and July 22,1983, concurred that GSA has the necessary statutory authority to conduct reviews of Federal agency information resources management activities. Separate triennial reviews of agency activities by OMB and GSA would be unnecessarily duplicative, which would not be consistent with the Act. Accordingly, the triennial reviews conducted by GSA will be designed to meet OMB’s requirements under the Paperwork Reduction Act as well as GSA's own needs. Senior Officials for Information Resources Management. In accordance with 44 U.S.C. 3506(b) and 5 CFR 1320.8, agencies are required to designate a senior official to carry out responsibilities under the Paperwork Reduction Act. The designation of the official is intended to assure clear accountability for setting policy for agency information resources management activities, provide for greater coordination among the agency’s information activities, and ensure greater visibility of such activities within the agency. The responsibilities of the senior official for information resources management were identified in OMB Bulletin No. 81-21* which has expired. Those responsibilities are now •estabished in this Circular. International Information Policy. The Circular deals with the management of information resources held by the Federal government. While the creation, collection, processing, transmission, dissemination, use, storage, and disposition of information by the Federal government has international ramifications, Federal government information resources management policy is not the same as “U.S. information policy," which refers to U.S. national interests in the information field vis-a-vis the policies and interests of other hâtions. The Circular formally acknowledges this distinction and assigns responsibilities for international information policy only insofar as it relates to Federal government information resources management policy. Timely Technology Procurement. Inherent in effective management of information technology is the ability of program managers to acquire technology in a timely manner. GSA is assigned the responsibility in Section 9 to develop criteria that will streamline procurement procedures and delegate procurement authority to agencies that comply with those procedures. All Federal agencies are directed in Section 9 to develop internal policies and procedures that further provide for timely acquisition of information technology. Records Management. The Paperwork Reduction Act makes the management of Federal records an integral part of information resources management. While no new policies are embodied in this Circular, responsibilities have been assigned in order to ensure that agency records management programs are considered within the context of Federal information resources management. Section 10. Oversight The broad scope of the Circular dictates a strategy of focusing oversight on a series of aspects of information resources management rather than on a single comprehensive reporting scheme. OMB intends to use existing mechanisms, such as the fiscal budget, information collection budget, and management reviews, to examine agency compliance with the Circular. For example, during 1984 the management reviews for the FY1986 budget year concentrated on five cross­ cutting information issues: overall information resources management strategy, telecommunications, software management, “electronic filing,” and end user computing. OMB issued data call bulletins requesting information specific to these issues, targeted the issues for special attention during the management reviews, and requested individual agencies to submit management improvement plans on specific aspects of the issues. Pursuit of this kind of selective oversight strategy permits OMB and the agencies the flexibility to shift the focus of oversight as information issues and the technological environment change. [FR Doc. 85-30330 Filed 12-23-85; 8:45 am] BILLING CODE 3110-01-M