[PDF page 1] EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET WASHINGTON, D.C. 20503 THE DIRECTOR November 18, 2013 M-14-03 MEMORANDUM FOR THE HEADS OF EXECUTIVE DEPARTMENTS AND AGENCIES FROM: S~lvia M. BurwefJ}\lfo Director SUBJECT: Enhancing the Security of Federal Information and Information Systems Our nation's security and economic prosperity depend on ensuring the confidentiality, integrity and availability ofFederal information and information systems. To strengthen the nation's cybersecurity posture, the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) identified cybersecurity as one of 14 Cross Agency Priority (CAP) Goals,1 established in accordance with · the Government Performance and Results Modernization Act? This memorandum provides agencies with guidance for managing infmmation security risk on a continuous basis and builds upon efforts towards achieving the cybersecurity CAP ·goal.3 The requirement to manage infmmation security risk on a continuous basis includes the requirement to monitor the security controls in Federal information systems and the environments in which those systems operate on an ongoing basis-one of six steps in the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) Risk Management Framework. 4 This allows agencies to maintain ongoing awareness of information security, vulnerabilities, and threats to support organizational risk management decisions. 5 · By strengthening the underlying information technology infrastructure through the application of state-of-the-art architectural and engineering solutions, and leveraging automation to support the implementation of the Risk Management Framework (which includes the ongoing monitoring of security controls), agencies can improve the effectiveness ofthe safeguards and countermeasures protecting federal information and infmmation systems in order to keep pace with the dynamic threat landscape. Another important benefit of having a robust program for managing information security risk on a continuous basis is the support it provides for ongoing authorization-that is, the ongoing determination and acceptance of information security risk. Rather than enforcing a static, point-in-time reauthorization process, agencies shall conduct ongoing authorizations of their information systems and environments in which those systems 1 The CAP goal helps agencies improve cybersecurity performance by focusing efforts on what data and information are entering and exiting their networks, who is on their systems, and what components are on their information networks as well as when their security statuses change. It accomplishes this by measuring agency implementation of Trusted In.temet Connections; strong authentication through the use of multi-factor authentication in accordance with Homeland Security Presidential Directive­ 12; and monitoring information systems' security controls on a continuous basis. 2 See http://goals.performance.gov/goals 2013. 3 The direction included in this memorandum applies to non-national security systems. 4 See NIST Special Publication 800-37 at: http://csrc.nist.gov/publications/PubsSPs.html. 5 See NIST Special Publication 800-137 at: http://csrc.nist.gov/publications/PubsSPs.html. [PDF page 2] operate, including common controls, 6 through the implementation of their risk management programs. Enhancing the security of information systems can also play an important role in protecting privacy by more thoroughly safeguarding the information in those systems. During the past year, the Federal Government has undertaken the following actions to support and accelerate agency implementation of effective risk management programs. In coordination with OMB, the Federal Chieflnformation Officer's Council (CIOC) and the Committee on National Security Systems (CNSS) established the Joint Continuous Monitoring Working Group (JCMWG), which developed the United States Government Concept of Operations (CONOPS) for Information Security Continuous Monitoring. This CONOPS supplements NIST guidelines by providing a roadmap and more specific implementation guidance to stakeholders across the Federal government. Agencies shall implement continuous monitoring of security controls 7 (step 6 in the Risk Management Framework) as part of a phased approach through Fiscal Year (FY) 2017.8 In conjunction with this effort, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has established a Continuous Diagnostics and Mitigation (CDM) Program. 9 Under this program, DHS coordinated with the General Services Administration (GSA) to establish a government­ wide Blanket Purchase Agreement (BP A) under Multiple Award Schedule 70, which Federal, State, local and tribal governments can leverage to deploy a basic set of capabilities to support continuous monitoring of security controls in Federal information systems and environments of operation. The BPA, awarded on August 1ih, 2013, provides a consistent, government-wide set of information security continuous monitoring (ISCM) tools to enhance the Federal government's ability to identify and respond, in real-time or near real-time, to the risk of emerging cyber threats. It also capitalizes on strategic sourcing to minimize the costs associated with implementing requirements of the Risk Management Framework. To fully implement ISCM across the Government, agencies shall: 1) Develop and maintain, consistent with existing statutes, OMB policy, NIST guidelines 10 and the CONOPS, an ISCM strategy, and establish an ISCM program that: a. Provides a clear understanding of organizational risk and helps officials set priorities and manage such risk consistently throughout the agency; and b. Addresses how the agency will conduct ongoing authorizations of information systems and the environments in which those systems operate, including the agency's use of common controls. 11 6 As defined in NIST Special Publication 800-37 located at: http://csrc.nist.gov/publications/PubsSPs.html. 7 Refers to the ongoing monitoring of security controls in Federal information systems and environments of operation. 8 Phase 1 focus areas are discussed in the CONOPS and on page 10 of this document. 9 The DHS CDM Program is one of the key components in a comprehensive ISCM program and is based upon NIST standards and guidelines. 10 NIST Special Publications 800-37; 800-39; 800-53; 800-53A; and 800-137 provide guidance on ISCM and are available at: http://csrc.nist.gov/publications/PubsSPs.html. 11 "Common Control" refers to a security control that is inherited by one or more organizational information systems. Refer to NIST SP 800-39 at: http://csrc.nist.gov/publications/PubsSPs.html. 2 [PDF page 3] 2) Establish plans, in coordination with DHS, to implement an agency ISCM program; 12 3) Standardize, to the extent practicable, the requirement to establish ISCM as an agency­ wide solution, deploying enterprise ISCM products and services instead of developing multiple, disparate services across agency bureaus and components; 13 4) Establish plans, to the extent practicable, to migrate to the GSA BPA as contract terms expire for acquisition vehicles currently used to acquire ISCM products and services. If an agency determines that it cannot use the GSA BP A, the agency Chief Operating Officer or the Deputy Secretary must submit a letter of attestation to the OMB Deputy Director for Management (and send a copy to egov@omb.eop.gov) with a justification as to why they cannot use the BP A, and demonstrate that the total cost to implement ISCM products and services from agency-specific or other contract vehicles is less than pricing available from the BP A; 5) Submit specified security-related information to the Federal ISCM dashboard maintained byDHS; 6) Evaluate and upgrade information systems and deploy new products, as needed, including agency and component ISCM dashboards, to support ISCM and the need to submit security-related information, as requested by OMB and DHS; 7) Require that external service providers hosting Federal information meet Federal information security requirements for ISCM. 14 This includes FedRAMP requirements for cloud computing; 15 and 8) Ensure adequate staff and training to meet the objectives of the ISCM program. In addition to the general agency responsibilities described above: 1) OMB will continue to oversee agency information security ~ractices, in accordance with the Federal Information Security Management Act of2002; 6 12 These plans can fully leverage the DHS CDM Program, provide for an agency-specific ISCM implementation or leverage a hybrid between the two. 13 These actions should be consistent with the OMB Memoranda M-11-29 and M-13-09. See http://www. whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/omb/memoranda/20 11/m11-29 .pdf and http://www. whitehouse. gov/sites/default/files/omb/memoranda/20 13/m-13 -09. pdf. 14 Federal Acquisition Regulation Pm1 7, Subpart 7 .I requires that agency planners of information technology acquisitions comply with the requirements in the Federal information Security Management Act, OMB's implementing policies, and NIST standards and guidelines. See http://www.acquisition.gov/far. 15 See https://cio.gov/wp-contentluploads/20 12/09/fedrampmemo.pdf. 16 See Public Law 107-347, Title III, Subchapter III, Section 3543 at http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/PLA W­ I 07publ34 7 /pdflPLA W -1 07publ34 7 .pdf 3 [PDF page 4] 2) DHS shall work with each agency to establish an ISCM implementation program that capitalizes on the processes established in the CONOPS and leverages, to the extent practicable, the BP A; 3) DHS, in consultation with OMB, shall establish a Federal dashboard for ISCM, which will provide a government-wide view ofiSCM, as well as the technical specifications and guidance for agencies on the requirements for submitting information to this Federal dashboard; 4) DHS, in coordination with OMB, shall monitor the implementation of agencies ISCM strategies and programs in conjunction with PortfolioStat 17 and through CyberStat; 18 5) The JCMWG, in coordination with stakeholders, shall update the CONOPS at least annually; and 6) NIST shall issue additional guidance on conducting ongoing authorizations. The transition from the three-year reauthorization approach to ongoing authorization should be in accordance with the level of maturity and effectiveness of agency ISCM programs, organizational risk tolerance, and subject to the final decision of authorizing officials. The attachment provides more specific direction and timelines for agencies to implement ISCM. For additional information on the DHS CDM Program, please contact cdm.fns@dhs.gov. For additional information regarding the GSA BP A, please contact cdm@gsa.gov or refer to http://www.gsa.gov/cdm. Questions relating to this policy may be directed to OMB at egov@omb.eop.gov. Attachment 17 See http://www. whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/omb/memoranda/20 12/m-12-10 1.pdf and http://www. whitehouse. gov/sites/default/files/ omb/memoranda/20 13/m-13 -09. pdf. 18 See http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/omb/memoranda/2012/m-12-20.pdf. 4 [PDF page 5] Attachment: This attachment outlines specific actions for agencies to follow in establishing their informFttion security continuous monitoring (ISCM) programs. Additional guidance will be provided, as needed, as the DHS Continuous Diagnostics and Mitigation (CDM) and agency programs mature. Contents Coordinate Federal ISCM Efforts ................................................................................................... 6 Develop, Maintain, and Implement ISCM Strategy ....................................................................... 6 Assess and Develop Staff and Resources ....................................................................................... 7 Procure Products and Services ........................................................................................................ 7 Deploy Products .............................................................................................................................. 8 Deploy ISCM Dashboards .............................................................................................................. 8 Implement ISCM .......................................................................................................................... 10 Provide for Ongoing Authorization and Re-authorization ............................................................ 10 Perform Independent Evaluations ................................................................................................. 12 Additional Info1mation ................................................................................................................. 12 Summary of Required Actions ...................................................................................................... 14 5 [PDF page 6] Coordinate Federal ISCM Efforts The Federal Chieflnformation Officer Council's Information Security and Identity Management Committee (ISIMC) along with the Committee on National Security Systems (CNSS) have established the Joint Continuous Monitoring Working Group (JCMWG) to provide consistent guidance for the ISCM 19 of both non-national security and national security systems. In support of ISCM, the JCMWG developed the United States Government Concept of Operations (CONOPS) for Information Security Continuous Monitoring?0 To support ISCM and the implementation of the DHS CDM Program, the JCMWG will continue to collaborate and coordinate with agencies and appropriate stakeholders to define the strategic and operational guidance for the successful implementation of ISCM throughout the federal government. Develop, Maintain, and Implement ISCM Strategy Agencies are required to develop and maintain an ISCM strategy and implement an ISCM program in accordance with NIST Special Publication 800-37, Guide for Applying the Risk Management Framework to Federal Information Systems: A Security Life Cycle Approach, NIST Special Publication 800-137, Information Security Continuous Monitoring (!SCM) for Federal Information Systems and Organizations, andNIST Special Publication 800-53, Security and Privacy Controls for Federal Information Systems and Organizations.21 Agencies should also follow implementation guidance outlined in the CONOPS. The ISCM strategies shall address all security controls selected and implemented by agencies, including the frequency of and degree of rigor associated with the monitoring process. 22 ISCM strategies, which must be approved by the appropriate agency authorizing official, shall also include all common controls inherited by organizational information systems. Additionally, all strategies must address the agencies' plans for transitioning to and maintaining consistency with Federal information security policies, standards, and guidelines. Agency officials shall monitor the security state of their information systems and the environments in which those systems operate on an ongoing basis with a frequency sufficient to make ongoing risk-based decisions on whether to continue to operate the systems within their organizations.23 19 ISCM is one part of a 3-tiered Risk Management Framework process as defined by NIST in Special Publication 800-39. See http://csrc.nist.gov/publications/PubsSPs.html. 20 While the CONOPS applies to national security systems and non-national security systems, this memorandum applies only to non-national security systems. The CONOPS is available at: https://max.omb.gov/community/x/7YFaE. 21 Agencies can develop either overarching (agency-wide/bureau/component/etc.) ISCM strategies that address all information systems or ISCM strategies for each agency information system. Such continuous strategies shall include the monitoring of all security controls (including common controls) at agency defined frequencies. 22 Security control selection and implementation refer to steps 2 and 3 ofthe NIST Risk Management Framework (RMF) which includes any tailoring activities applied by agencies to the initial security control baselines. Security controls selected and implemented by agencies (including common controls, hybrid controls, and system-specific controls) are documented in associated security plans. 23 Rather than enforcing a static, three-year reauthorization process, agencies are expected to conduct ongoing authorizations of information systems. This includes the ongoing authorization of common controls inherited by organizational information systems. ISCM programs fulfill the three-year security reauthorization requirement required by Circular A-130 (dated November 2000), so a separate reauthorization process is not necessary. 6 [PDF page 7] Develop ISCM strategy (or February 28, 2014 All agencies strategies) Assess and Develop Staff and Resources Agencies shall ensure adequate staff and training are in place to meet the objectives of the ISCM program. To support agencies' implementations, DHS will coordinate interagency advisory and user groups and provide training and mentoring to agency managers on how to implement ISCM. For those agencies obtaining ISCM services offered through the DHS CDM Program, contract support will be provided to help implement sensors across multiple agencies to reduce the leaming curve and provide consistent implementation. Agencies shall ensure any additional budget needs are addressed during the development of their annual budget. ··'·'. I"Requil'¢Ci A.6tihh'. ··.·... ····.•.. ··...·•. ·.•....... ::·.r. p~~4liil.e•: .··• {).~ •·.··· ·\·R.espob.sible£t1fity'~ ,J . -:-. ... . .. .··. . .• ... Identify resource and skill requirement gaps (if any) to manage and coordinate the intemal ISCM program April30, 2014 All agencies Identify specific individuals to manage the agency ISCM program April30, 2014 All agencies Procure Products and Services DHS has worked with GSA to make available products and services (including ISCM dashboards) to support the implementation of ISCM through strategic sourcing. Unless agencies have already procured ISCM products and services to support Phase 1 focus areas,24 procurements for the time lines below apply to all agencies regardless of whether or not they use the GSA BP A for ISCM products and services. Agencies shall identify capability gaps and procure products and services, as needed, to implement their ISCM strategy. In addressing gaps, agencies should leverage, to the extent practicable, the GSA BP A. The initial suite of products available on the GSA BP A covers hardware asset management, software asset management (including malware management), configuration setting management, and common vulnerability management (from the National Vulnerability Database).25 The suite of products will eventually be expanded to cover additional capabilities, to support future phases as outlined in the CONOPS and NIST security controls. Services may include operation and maintenance of these products as well as integration of security-related information gathered through the ISCM process into the appropriate dashboards. To the extent that agencies reduce their ISCM costs by leveraging the GSA BP A and participating in the DHS CDM program, those agencies shall reinvest the savings to improve their risk management processes. As agencies transition from traditional static (i.e., point-in­ time driven) assessment and authorization processes to ongoing assessment and authorization 24 Phase I focus areas are discussed in the CONOPS and on page 10 ofthis document. 25 See http://nvd.nist.gov/. 7 [PDF page 8] processes, they are expected to leverage their existing funding to implement ISCM. The DHS CDM program funding may be used to address gaps in products and services for civilian agencies.26 ~ ·.. -,; ... ·' . .:··· ....... ·.· c :Resp(nl.sible J:j:fltit)i ·••·····•·• >•.cl)~('l.dlin~ ;<;:,_,, .. •. . . . . . . . ., '. .; . ; .. . . .•R~ql}i}~d;.f\.6tion: .·••··• / ~ , .?. Complete CDM foundational Immediately, if not All civilian agencies survey and return to DHS already completed Sign Memorandum of Agreement Immediately, ifnot All civilian agencies (MOA) with DHS already completed receiving DHS CDM services Begin to procure products and February 28, 2014 All agencies services to support Phase 1 focus areas (as described in the CONOPS) Deploy Products Agencies shall evaluate capability gaps, upgrade their infrastructure and deploy new products, as needed, to support ISCM and the requirement to automate the submission of security-related information to OMB and DHS. As outlined in the CONOPS, agencies have a variety of options when implementing their ISCM technical architecture, which include: a. Leveraging the services and products offered by the DHS CDM Program; b. Leveraging the agency's existing products and services; and/or c. Implementing a hybrid approach where agencies can leverage the DHS CDM Program to procure products, for example, but implementing it using their own hardware. Begin to deploy products to May 30, 2014 All agencies support ISCM of all systems Ensure all information systems are May 30, 2014 All agencies authorized to operate in accordance with Federal requirements prior to initiating ISCM for those systems Deploy ISCM Dashboards Beginning in FY 2014, all agencies must submit security-related information to an extensible ISCM dashboard for agency-level and Federal government-wide views. A standard set of dashboards will help agencies use the security-related information on a daily basis to identify and address their highest priority security issues. DHS shall establish the Federal dashboard through 26 DHS CDM program funding may only be used to assist the Executive branch civilian agencies, excluding DOD and the intelligence community. Please see Public Law 113-6, Division D, Title V, Section 558, subsection (e) at http://www. gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/BILLS-113hr933enr/pd£'BILLS-113hr933enr.pdf. 8 [PDF page 9] which agencies shall report security-related information. The Federal dashboard will be maintained by DRS, and will be focused on managing the highest priority and most serious risks based on risk assessment information and the risk tolerance established by individual agencies. DRS, in consultation with OMB, will provide guidance for security-related information and associated technical specifications required to be repmted to the Federal dashboard. The Federal dashboard, maintained by DRS, shall provide information on specific vulnerabilities identified that could lead to adverse impacts to missions/business functions? 7 It will also supply data on agency performance for use by oversight entities to help identify the level of risk reduction which is both possible and beneficial for agencies (depending on their risk-based needs). Data gathered from the Federal dashboard will be used by DRS to develop guidance for agencies with the intent of improving decision making regarding risk/cost tradeoffs. For agencies obtaining services offered by the DRS CDM Program, integration of products with DRS supplied dashboards shall be provided. In the event an agency uses sensor products other than those offered through the GSA BPA as part ofthe CDM Program, the agency shall be responsible for providing required security-related information to the DRS-supplied dashboard. Once the DRS-supplied dashboard is integrated with the products (e.g., sensors), it is the expectation ofthe DRS CDM Program that minimal agency effort will be required to provide the necessary security-related information to the Federal dashboard. Regardless of the implementation approach, all agencies shall deliver security-related information to the DRS supplied dashboard(s) in accordance with requirements provided by DRS, in coordination with OMB. Additionally, it is the sole responsibility of the agency to respond to risks identified as a result of the ISCM program? 8 ·:B.etfllif~(f•A:ct.i: \ . ·. ··•· <; )Deadline ·:·~~J{esP'Oris.ibJ~:IiiiJity··· ·· ' " . . .. . .. •. . . :.;, .•• Develop ISCM strategy (or All agencies strategies) February 28, 2014 Identify resource and skill April 30, 2014 All agencies requirement gaps (if any) to manage and coordinate the internal ISCM program April30, 2014 All agencies manage the agency ISCM program Identify specific individuals to All civilian agencies and return to DHS Complete CDM foundational survey Immediately, if not already completed All civilian agencies (MOA) with DHS Immediately, ifnot already Sign Memorandum ofAgreement receiving DHS CDM services completed All agencies services to support Phase 1 focus areas (as described in the CONOPS) February 28, 2014 Begin to procure products and May 30,2014 All agencies ISCM for all systems Begin to deploy products to support All agencies authorized to operate in accordance with Federal requirements prior to initiating ISCM for those systems Ensure all information systems are May 30,2014 3 months prior to DHS agency data feeds for Phase I focus Publish technical specifications for deployment ofthe Federal areas to the Federal dashboard dashboard 14 [PDF page 15] .:,..:· ·:' :· .·R~cr¥red:A.9tion' :< . · Ensure that all Phase 1 products necessary to meet DHS reporting requirements provide data compatible with the Federal dashboard maintained by DHS Complete installation of agency and bureau/ component-level dashboards Begin submitting automated data feeds for Phase 1 focus areas to the Federal dashboard Analyze, and respond to vulnerabilities identified on the local dashboards Publish guidance establishing a process and criteria for agencies to conduct ongoing assessments and authorizations Update ISCM strategies to describe the process for performing ongoing authorizations Determine whether agencies have documented their ISCM strategy Assess whether agencies have implemented ISCM for information technology assets Evaluate agencies' risk assessments used to develop their ISCM strategy Verify that agencies conduct and report on ISCM results in accordance with their continuous monitoring strategy ·.':.'• • ......... I)~~dlili~··., ... ,.. ~·.·.. Within 3 months ofthe Federal dashboard being deployed Within 6 months ofthe Federal dashboard being deployed Within 6 months ofthe Federal dashboard being deployed Starting immediately upon activation of local dashboards March 31, 2014 Within 3 months of receiving additional guidance in this area (either from the NIST, DHS, and/or the JCMWG) November 15, 2014 (and each year thereafter) November 15, 2014 (and each year thereafter) ' November 15, 2014 (and each year thereafter) November 15,2014 (and each year thereafter) ·~:_C'ResJfo~siBleElidt)tX·:,)• All agencies All agencies All agencies All agencies NIST All agencies Inspectors General Inspectors General Inspectors General Inspectors General 15